Institute of Medicine, Chung Shan Medical University, Taichung, Taiwan.
School of Medicine, Chung Shan Medical University, Taichung, Taiwan.
Sci Rep. 2019 Feb 18;9(1):2168. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-38428-z.
There are no clinical guidelines for the timing of cholecystectomy (CCY) after performing therapeutic endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) for choledocholithiasis. We tried to analyze the clinical practice patterns, medical expenses, and subsequent outcomes between the early CCY, delayed CCY, and no CCY groups of patients. 1827 choledocholithiasis patients who underwent therapeutic ERCP were selected from the nationwide population databases of two million random samples. These patients were further divided into early CCY, delayed CCY, and no CCY performed. In our analysis, 1440 (78.8%) of the 1827 patients did not undergo CCY within 60 days of therapeutic ERCP, and only 239 (13.1%) patients underwent CCY during their index admission. The proportion of laparoscopic CCY increased from 37.2% to 73.6% in the delayed CCY group. There were no significant differences (p = 0.934) between recurrent biliary event (RBE) rates with or without early CCY within 60 days of ERCP. RBE event-free survival rates were significantly different in the early CCY (85.04%), delayed CCY (89.54%), and no CCY (64.45%) groups within 360 days of ERCP. The method of delayed CCY can reduce subsequent RBEs and increase the proportion of laparoscopic CCY with similar medical expenses to early CCY in Taiwan's general practice environment.
对于胆总管结石患者,行治疗性内镜逆行胰胆管造影术(ERCP)后何时行胆囊切除术(CCY)并无临床指南。我们试图分析行治疗性 ERCP 后的胆总管结石患者中,早期行 CCY、延迟行 CCY 和不行 CCY 三组的临床实践模式、医疗费用和后续结果。从全国两百万随机抽样人群数据库中选择了 1827 例行治疗性 ERCP 的胆总管结石患者。这些患者进一步分为早期 CCY、延迟 CCY 和不行 CCY 三组。在我们的分析中,1827 例患者中有 1440 例(78.8%)在 ERCP 治疗后 60 天内未行 CCY,仅有 239 例(13.1%)患者在住院期间行 CCY。延迟 CCY 组中腹腔镜 CCY 的比例从 37.2%增加到 73.6%。ERCP 后 60 天内行早期 CCY 与不行 CCY 之间的复发性胆道事件(RBE)发生率无显著差异(p=0.934)。ERCP 后 360 天内,早期 CCY(85.04%)、延迟 CCY(89.54%)和不行 CCY(64.45%)组的 RBE 无事件生存曲线有显著差异。在台湾的一般医疗环境下,延迟 CCY 方法可降低后续 RBE 发生率,并增加腹腔镜 CCY 的比例,其医疗费用与早期 CCY 相似。