Gupta Sandeep, Das Susanta Kumar, Jana Debarshi, Pal Dilip Kumar
Department of Urology, Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, Kolkata, West Bengal, India.
Urol Ann. 2019 Jan-Mar;11(1):33-38. doi: 10.4103/UA.UA_191_17.
This study aims to compare the various distraction methods used during office cystoscopy to decrease pain and dissatisfaction among patients.
Two hundred patients undergoing rigid cystoscopy between January 2017 and July 2017 were randomized into four groups of 50 patients: (1) Group I: Patients who listened to music during the cystoscopy, (2) Group II: Patients allowed real-time visualization of the cystoscopy, (3) Group III: Patients who listened to music and had real-time visualization of the procedure, (4) Group IV: Control group undergoing cystoscopy without any distraction used. A visual analog scale (VAS) (1-10) was used for a self-assessment of pain, satisfaction, and willingness for repeat cystoscopy.
Demographic characteristics, mean age, procedure duration, and procedure indications were statistically similar between the four groups. The mean VAS pain score were significantly lower in the three study Groups (I, II, and III) where distraction methods were used during cystoscopies as compared to the control Group IV ( < 0.001) and the satisfaction VAS scores and VAS scores for willingness to undergo a repeat procedure were significantly higher in the study groups ( < 0.001). Statistically significant decreased postprocedural pulse rate and blood pressure in comparison with to their preprocedural values were observed when distraction methods were used ( < 0.01). Patients undergoing cystoscopies listening to music and real-time visualization (Group III) had better VAS scores than the others ( < 0.01).
Distraction methods reduce pain and increase satisfaction among patients. Best results are with combined listening to music and direct real-time visualization.
本研究旨在比较门诊膀胱镜检查期间使用的各种分散注意力方法,以减轻患者的疼痛并降低其不满意程度。
2017年1月至2017年7月期间接受硬式膀胱镜检查的200例患者被随机分为四组,每组50例:(1)第一组:膀胱镜检查期间听音乐的患者;(2)第二组:可实时观看膀胱镜检查过程的患者;(3)第三组:听音乐并能实时观看检查过程的患者;(4)第四组:未使用任何分散注意力方法而接受膀胱镜检查的对照组。采用视觉模拟评分法(VAS,1 - 10分)对疼痛、满意度及再次接受膀胱镜检查的意愿进行自我评估。
四组患者的人口统计学特征、平均年龄、手术持续时间及手术指征在统计学上相似。与对照组第四组相比,在膀胱镜检查期间使用分散注意力方法的三个研究组(第一组、第二组和第三组)的平均VAS疼痛评分显著更低(<0.001),研究组的满意度VAS评分及再次接受手术意愿的VAS评分显著更高(<0.001)。使用分散注意力方法时,与术前值相比,术后脉搏率和血压在统计学上有显著下降(<0.01)。听音乐并实时观看检查过程的膀胱镜检查患者(第三组)的VAS评分优于其他组(<0.01)。
分散注意力方法可减轻患者疼痛并提高满意度。听音乐与直接实时观看相结合效果最佳。