Rapoport L M, Bezrukov E A, Tsarichenko D G, Martirosyan G A, Sukhanov R B, Krupinov G E, Slusarenco R I, Morozov A O, Avakyan S K, Sargsyan N A
Research Institute of Uronephrology and Human Reproductive Health, I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia.
University clinic of Urology, I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, Moscow, Russia.
Khirurgiia (Mosk). 2019(1):89-94. doi: 10.17116/hirurgia201901189.
Robotic surgery is a future method of minimal invasive surgery. Robot-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP) is a common method of surgical treatment of prostate cancer. Due to significant differences of the surgical technique of RARP compared to open or laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (LRP) new methods of training are needed. At the moment there are many opinions how to train physicians best. Which model is the most effective one remains nowadays controversial.
Analyze currently available data of training methods of RARP. Determine the most effective training model and evaluate its advantages and disadvantages. Establish a standardized plan and criteria for proper training and certification of the entire surgical team.
Literature review based on PubMed database, Web of Science and Scopus by keywords: robot-assisted radical prostatectomy, training of robot-assisted prostatectomy, training in robot-assisted operations, a learning curve of robot-assisted prostatectomy, virtual reality simulators (VR-simulators) in surgery.
According to the literature in average 18 to 45 procedures are required for a surgeon to achieve the plateau of the learning curve of the RARP. Parallel training, pre-operative warm-up and the use of virtual reality simulators (VR-simulators) can significantly increase the learning curve. There are many described models of RARP training.
The absence of accepted criteria of evaluation of the learning curve does not allow to use this parameter as a guide for the surgeon's experience. Proper training of robotic surgeons is necessary and requires new methods of training. There are different types of training programs. In our opinion the most effective training program is when a surgeon observes the performance of tasks or any steps of operation on the VR-simulator, then he performs them and analyzes mistakes by video recording. Then the surgeon observes real operations and performs some steps of the operation which are already leant on the simulator under supervision of the mentor and analyzes mistakes by video recording. Thus, mastering first the simple stages under supervision of a mentor, the surgeon effectively adopts the surgical experience from him. It is necessary to train not only the surgeons but also the entire surgical team.
机器人手术是未来的微创手术方法。机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术(RARP)是前列腺癌手术治疗的常用方法。由于RARP的手术技术与开放或腹腔镜根治性前列腺切除术(LRP)相比有显著差异,因此需要新的培训方法。目前对于如何最佳地培训医生有很多观点。哪种模式最有效目前仍存在争议。
分析RARP目前可用的培训方法数据。确定最有效的培训模式并评估其优缺点。为整个手术团队的适当培训和认证制定标准化计划和标准。
基于PubMed数据库、科学网和Scopus进行文献综述,关键词为:机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术、机器人辅助前列腺切除术培训、机器人辅助手术培训、机器人辅助前列腺切除术的学习曲线、手术中的虚拟现实模拟器(VR模拟器)。
根据文献,外科医生平均需要进行18至45例手术才能达到RARP学习曲线的平稳期。并行培训、术前热身和使用虚拟现实模拟器(VR模拟器)可显著提高学习曲线。有许多描述的RARP培训模式。
缺乏公认的学习曲线评估标准使得无法将该参数用作衡量外科医生经验的指南。对机器人外科医生进行适当培训是必要的,且需要新的培训方法。有不同类型的培训项目。我们认为最有效的培训项目是外科医生先在VR模拟器上观察任务执行或任何手术步骤,然后自己执行并通过视频记录分析错误。接着外科医生观察实际手术并在导师监督下执行在模拟器上已学过的一些手术步骤,并通过视频记录分析错误。这样,外科医生在导师监督下先掌握简单阶段,就能有效地从导师那里汲取手术经验。不仅要培训外科医生,还要培训整个手术团队。