Wilson Alexandra, Hurwitz Craig A, Smith Monica, Patino Tracy, Kudalmana Arya S, Gallas Michelle
J Grad Med Educ. 2019 Feb;11(1):60-65. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-18-00180.1.
Physicians often lack the skills and confidence needed to have difficult conversations with patients and their families. Patients and families who have experienced these conversations can provide valuable insight for resident physicians.
We developed a communication skills workshop for pediatrics residents using parents and a team of social workers, nurses, chaplains, and physician facilitators in role-playing exercises.
From 2007 to 2016, half-day "difficult conversation" workshops were held annually for postgraduate year 1 (PGY-1) and PGY-2 residents that included an interprofessional team and parents of children with life-threatening diagnoses. Questionnaires assessed residents' prior training, effectiveness of the sessions, and narrative feedback on the impact of this approach. Parents and team members were surveyed on the effectiveness of the training and the value of parent involvement.
Median self-reported confidence levels for incoming PGY-1 residents following the workshop rose from 2 to 4 on a 5-point Likert scale (99% response rate [128 of 129 surveyed], < .001). The majority of PGY-2 residents (91%, 115 of 126) reported the workshop increased their confidence in engaging in difficult conversations (91% response rate [126 of 139]). Parents and clinical care team members agreed that parents would likely be preferable to standardized actors for these types of role-playing exercises (84% response rate [37 of 44]).
Involving patients' parents and an interprofessional team in role-playing scenarios was a well-received method for teaching residents how to engage in difficult conversations with patients and families, and improved their self-reported confidence when having these conversations.
医生常常缺乏与患者及其家属进行艰难对话所需的技能和信心。经历过此类对话的患者及其家属能够为住院医师提供宝贵的见解。
我们为儿科住院医师开发了一个沟通技能工作坊,让家长以及一组社会工作者、护士、牧师和医师主持人参与角色扮演练习。
从2007年到2016年,每年为第一年住院医师(PGY - 1)和第二年住院医师举办为期半天的“艰难对话”工作坊,其中包括一个跨专业团队以及患有危及生命诊断疾病儿童的家长。通过问卷调查评估住院医师之前接受的培训、课程的有效性以及关于这种方法影响的叙述性反馈。对家长和团队成员就培训的有效性以及家长参与的价值进行了调查。
参加工作坊后,PGY - 1住院医师自我报告的信心水平中位数在5分制李克特量表上从2升至4(回复率99%[129名受访者中的128名],P < 0.001)。大多数PGY - 2住院医师(91%,126名中的115名)报告该工作坊增强了他们进行艰难对话的信心(回复率91%[139名中的126名])。家长和临床护理团队成员一致认为,在这类角色扮演练习中,家长可能比标准化演员更合适(回复率84%[44名中的37名])。
让患者家长和跨专业团队参与角色扮演场景是一种广受好评的方法,用于教导住院医师如何与患者及其家属进行艰难对话,并提高他们在进行这些对话时自我报告的信心。