Dudash Mark J, Slipak Sasha, Dove James, Hunsinger Marie, Wild Jeffrey, Shabahang Mohsen, Arora Tania K, Blansfield Joseph A
Am Surg. 2019 Feb 1;85(2):201-205.
Surgical therapy for esophageal cancer is the cornerstone of treatment, and the highest quality operation should lead to the highest cure rate. Evaluated lymph node (ELN) count is one quality measure that has been championed. The objective of this study was to explore ELN in esophagectomy, examine predictors of harvesting ≥12 nodes, and determine whether higher ELN improves overall survival (OS). ELN was examined in patients with resected esophageal cancer using the National Cancer Database from 2004 to 2013. In this study, 41,746 patients met the inclusion criteria. Fifty-two per cent of patients had 12 or more nodes harvested. Academic programs were most likely to harvest ≥12 nodes (58% of cases) compared with other programs (43-56% of cases). Seventy per cent of cases with ≥12 nodes harvested were performed at high-volume centers. Preoperative radiation or preoperative chemoradiation led to lower ELN (46% and 48%) preoperative chemotherapy alone (66%). Multivariate analysis showed that patients who had ≥12 nodes removed had better OS (Hazard Ratio 0.843 [95 confidence interval 0.820-0.867]). In addition, care at a high-volume facility, care at an academic facility, private insurance, and income ≥$63,000 were all associated with improved OS. Higher ELN count is associated with OS in patients with esophageal cancer. Patients who receive care at high-volume centers and academic centers are more likely to undergo more extensive lymphadenectomy. All centers should strive to examine at least 12 nodes to provide a quality esophagectomy.
食管癌的手术治疗是治疗的基石,最高质量的手术应带来最高的治愈率。评估淋巴结(ELN)计数是一项备受推崇的质量指标。本研究的目的是探讨食管癌切除术中的ELN,检查获取≥12枚淋巴结的预测因素,并确定更高的ELN是否能改善总生存期(OS)。利用2004年至2013年的国家癌症数据库对接受食管癌切除术的患者的ELN进行了检查。在本研究中,41746例患者符合纳入标准。52%的患者获取了12枚或更多的淋巴结。与其他机构(43%-56%的病例)相比,学术机构最有可能获取≥12枚淋巴结(58%的病例)。获取≥12枚淋巴结的病例中,70%是在高容量中心进行的。术前放疗或术前放化疗导致ELN较低(分别为46%和48%),单纯术前化疗为66%。多因素分析显示,切除≥12枚淋巴结的患者OS更好(风险比0.843[95%置信区间0.820-0.867])。此外,在高容量机构接受治疗、在学术机构接受治疗、拥有私人保险以及收入≥63000美元均与OS改善相关。食管癌患者中较高的ELN计数与OS相关。在高容量中心和学术中心接受治疗的患者更有可能接受更广泛的淋巴结清扫。所有中心都应努力检查至少12枚淋巴结,以提供高质量的食管癌切除术。