Department of Clinical Psychology, Fuller Theological Seminary, Pasadena, CA, USA.
School of Sociology, China University of Political Science and Law, Beijing, China.
J Relig Health. 2020 Feb;59(1):318-333. doi: 10.1007/s10943-019-00784-z.
In China, many people are converting to various world religions. Nonetheless, religious adherence for them, as with many people, can still function as a double-edged sword with regards to mental health. In particular, religious perfection can become either a healthy commitment or a rigid outlook that leads to distress. Thus, we developed the Religious Perfectionism Scale (RPS) from Chinese religious believers. In the first phase (N = 171), we collected qualitative data through an open-question survey from different religious groups (i.e., Buddhism, Protestantism, and Islam). Then, we developed an item pool based on themes that emerged from these qualitative data. In the second phase, participants (N = 1055) were randomly split into two subsamples. Exploratory factor analyses were performed on the first subsample (N = 519) to select the scale items. The nine-item RPS subsequently includes two dimensions-Zealous Religious Dedication and Religious Self-Criticism. Confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) were performed on the second subsample (N = 536) to cross-validate the factor structure. Results indicate that the internal consistency reliability for the RPS subscale scores was all adequate. Furthermore, the construct validity of the RPS was supported through its correlations with measures of perfectionism perceived to have come from God (or a higher power), psychological indicators, and a personality variable (i.e., discipline) in expected directions. Results of the psychometric evaluations of this newly developed scale suggest that the RPS is a promising measure in that it can facilitate future research that leads to a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of religious perfectionism on psychological well-being.
在中国,许多人皈依各种世界宗教。然而,与许多人一样,宗教信仰对他们的心理健康可能仍然是一把双刃剑。特别是,宗教完美主义可能成为一种健康的承诺,也可能成为一种导致痛苦的僵化观念。因此,我们从中国宗教信徒中开发了宗教完美主义量表(RPS)。在第一阶段(N=171),我们通过不同宗教团体(即佛教、新教和伊斯兰教)的开放式问题调查收集定性数据。然后,我们根据这些定性数据中出现的主题开发了一个项目库。在第二阶段,参与者(N=1055)被随机分为两个子样本。对第一个子样本(N=519)进行探索性因素分析,以选择量表项目。随后的九项 RPS 包括两个维度——狂热的宗教奉献和宗教自我批评。在第二个子样本(N=536)上进行验证性因素分析(CFA)以交叉验证该因子结构。结果表明,RPS 子量表得分的内部一致性信度均足够。此外,通过与被认为来自上帝(或更高的力量)的完美主义测量、心理指标以及人格变量(即纪律)的相关性,支持了 RPS 的建构效度。该新开发量表的心理计量学评估结果表明,RPS 是一种有前途的测量工具,因为它可以促进未来的研究,从而更全面地了解宗教完美主义对心理健康的影响。