The Australian Centre for Public and Population Health Research, Sydney.
The Centre for Health Services Management, Faculty of Health, University of Technology Sydney, Sydney.
Acad Emerg Med. 2019 Sep;26(9):1052-1062. doi: 10.1111/acem.13721. Epub 2019 Mar 25.
Emergency departments (EDs) are essential providers of compassionate, immediate treatment and referral for women experiencing intimate partner violence (IPV). IPV, largely perpetrated by men against women, exerts a substantial burden on the health systems and economies of all nations. There is little known about how staff in Australian EDs respond to the challenges such violence generates. We therefore examined the clinical team response to women experiencing IPV in two large Australian metropolitan hospital EDs.
We undertook qualitative semistructured interviews and focus group discussions with 35 social workers, nurses, and doctors. Transcripts were recorded and transcribed verbatim. We analyzed the data thematically. We first undertook line-by-line coding and organized content into descriptive categories. Latent and manifest patterns were identified across the data and mapped to key themes in negotiation with all authors.
Respondents emphasized challenges identifying IPV resulting from professional uncertainty or discomfort and women's fear of the ramifications of disclosure. Emergency clinicians routinely referred women to social workers after medical treatment and described effective collaboration across professions. Social workers outlined difficulties coordinating care with health and community agencies. Staff highlighted challenges maintaining nonjudgmental attitudes and managing their own feelings-especially clinicians who had personally experienced violence.
Emergency departments can provide caring environments for women experiencing IPV. Effective interprofessional teamwork across nursing, medical, and social work professionals may mitigate the need for formal screening tools. Supportive workforce environments can improve staff understanding, reduce stigma, enhance appropriate treatment, and counsel health professionals experiencing violence. However, staff training and advocacy and referral relationships with local programs require strengthening. A connected multisystems-level response is required to coordinate and resource services for all affected by violence.
急诊科是为遭受亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)的女性提供富有同情心的即时治疗和转介服务的重要场所。这种暴力行为主要由男性对女性实施,给所有国家的卫生系统和经济造成了巨大负担。目前,人们对澳大利亚急诊科工作人员如何应对这种暴力带来的挑战知之甚少。因此,我们研究了两家澳大利亚大都市医院急诊科的临床团队对遭受 IPV 的女性的应对方式。
我们对 35 名社会工作者、护士和医生进行了定性半结构式访谈和焦点小组讨论。记录并逐字转录了转录本。我们对数据进行了主题分析。我们首先进行逐行编码,并将内容组织成描述性类别。通过与所有作者协商,确定了数据中的潜在和明显模式,并将其映射到关键主题。
受访者强调了由于专业不确定性或不适以及女性对披露后果的恐惧而导致难以识别 IPV 的挑战。急诊临床医生通常在医疗治疗后将女性转介给社会工作者,并描述了跨专业合作的有效性。社会工作者概述了在与健康和社区机构协调护理方面的困难。工作人员强调了保持非评判态度和管理自己情绪的挑战,尤其是那些亲身经历过暴力的临床医生。
急诊科可以为遭受 IPV 的女性提供关怀的环境。护理、医疗和社会工作专业人员之间有效的跨专业团队合作可能有助于减少对正式筛查工具的需求。支持性的工作环境可以提高工作人员的理解能力,减少耻辱感,加强适当的治疗,并为遭受暴力的卫生专业人员提供咨询。然而,需要加强工作人员培训、宣传以及与当地项目的转介关系。需要建立一个相互关联的多系统水平的响应,以协调和为所有受暴力影响的人提供资源。