Elgendi Mohamed, Menon Carlo
Menrva Research Group, Schools of Mechatronic Systems Engineering and Engineering Science, Simon Fraser University, Surrey, BC V3T 0A3, Canada.
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, Canada.
Brain Sci. 2019 Mar 1;9(3):50. doi: 10.3390/brainsci9030050.
Wearable devices (WD) are starting to increasingly be used for interventions to promote well-being by reducing anxiety disorders (AD). Electrocardiogram (ECG) signal is one of the most commonly used biosignals for assessing the cardiovascular system as it significantly reflects the activity of the autonomic nervous system during emotional changes. Little is known about the accuracy of using ECG features for detecting ADs. Moreover, during our literature review, a limited number of studies were found that involve ECG collection using WD for promoting mental well-being. Thus, for the sake of validating the reliability of ECG features for detecting anxiety in WD, we screened 1040 articles, and only 22 were considered for our study; specifically 6 on panic, 4 on post-traumatic stress, 4 on generalized anxiety, 3 on social, 3 on mixed, and 2 on obsessive-compulsive anxiety disorder articles. Most experimental studies had controversial results. Upon reviewing each of these papers, it became apparent that the use of ECG features for detecting different types of anxiety is controversial, and the use of ECG-WD is an emerging area of research, with limited evidence suggesting its reliability. Due to the clinical nature of most studies, it is difficult to determine the specific impact of ECG features on detecting ADs, suggesting the need for more robust studies following our proposed recommendations.
可穿戴设备(WD)正开始越来越多地用于通过减少焦虑症(AD)来促进幸福感的干预措施。心电图(ECG)信号是评估心血管系统最常用的生物信号之一,因为它能在情绪变化期间显著反映自主神经系统的活动。关于使用心电图特征检测焦虑症的准确性,人们了解甚少。此外,在我们的文献综述过程中,发现涉及使用可穿戴设备收集心电图以促进心理健康的研究数量有限。因此,为了验证心电图特征在可穿戴设备中检测焦虑症的可靠性,我们筛选了1040篇文章,只有22篇被纳入我们的研究;具体来说,6篇关于恐慌症,4篇关于创伤后应激障碍,4篇关于广泛性焦虑症,3篇关于社交焦虑症,3篇关于混合型焦虑症,2篇关于强迫症焦虑症的文章。大多数实验研究都有争议性结果。在审阅每一篇此类论文时,很明显,使用心电图特征检测不同类型的焦虑症存在争议,并且使用可穿戴设备记录心电图是一个新兴的研究领域,仅有有限的证据表明其可靠性。由于大多数研究的临床性质,很难确定心电图特征对检测焦虑症的具体影响,这表明需要按照我们提出的建议开展更有力的研究。