International Vaccine Access Center, Department of International Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland.
Center for Vaccine Innovation and Access, PATH, Geneva, Switzerland.
Clin Infect Dis. 2019 Mar 7;68(Suppl 2):S83-S95. doi: 10.1093/cid/ciy1122.
Typhoid places a substantial economic burden on low- and middle-income countries. We performed a literature review and critical overview of typhoid-related economic issues to inform vaccine introduction. We searched 4 literature databases, covering 2000-2017, to identify typhoid-related cost-of-illness (COI) studies, cost-of-delivery studies, cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs), and demand forecast studies. Manual bibliographic searches of reviews revealed studies in the gray literature. Planned studies were identified in conference proceedings and through partner organization outreach. We identified 29 published, unpublished, and planned studies. Published COI studies revealed a substantial burden in Asia, with hospitalization costs alone ranging from $159 to $636 (in 2016 US$) in India, but there was less evidence for the burden in Africa. Cost-of-delivery studies are largely unpublished, but 1 study found that $671 000 in government investments would avert $60 000 in public treatment costs. CEA evidence was limited, but generally found targeted vaccination programs to be cost-effective. This review revealed insufficient economic evidence for vaccine introduction. Countries considering vaccine introduction should have access to relevant economic evidence to aid in decision-making and planning. Planned studies will fill many of the existing gaps in the literature.
伤寒对中低收入国家造成了巨大的经济负担。我们对伤寒相关经济问题进行了文献回顾和批判性综述,为疫苗接种提供信息。我们搜索了 4 个文献数据库,涵盖了 2000 年至 2017 年,以确定与伤寒相关的疾病成本(COI)研究、提供成本研究、成本效益分析(CEA)和需求预测研究。对综述的手动文献检索揭示了灰色文献中的研究。在会议记录和通过伙伴组织外联中确定了计划中的研究。我们确定了 29 项已发表、未发表和计划中的研究。已发表的 COI 研究表明,亚洲的负担很重,仅在印度,住院费用就高达 159 至 636 美元(按 2016 年美元计算),但非洲的负担证据较少。提供成本研究主要是未发表的,但有一项研究发现,政府投资 67.1 万美元可避免 6 万美元的公共治疗费用。CEA 的证据有限,但普遍认为有针对性的疫苗接种计划具有成本效益。这项综述显示,伤寒疫苗接种的经济证据不足。考虑引入疫苗的国家应该能够获得相关的经济证据,以帮助决策和规划。计划中的研究将填补文献中许多现有的空白。