a Department of Public Health Sciences , The University of Chicago Biological Sciences , Chicago , IL , USA.
b World Bank Global Road Safety Facility , The World Bank , Washington , DC , USA.
Health Syst Reform. 2019;5(2):121-133. doi: 10.1080/23288604.2019.1565061. Epub 2019 Mar 8.
Traffic injuries remain a leading health concern in most low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). However, most LMICs have not established institutions that have the legislative mandate and financial resources necessary to coordinate large-scale interventions. Argentina provides a counterexample. Argentina is a federal country where the decentralization of authority to provincial governments was a key barrier to effective national interventions. In 2008, Argentina passed a law establishing a national road safety agency and subsequently received a World Bank loan to build the agency's capacity to coordinate actions. Although traffic injuries in Argentina have not yet begun to decline, these developments raise important questions:We explore these questions using a descriptive case study (single-case, holistic design) of Argentina. The case illustrates that focusing events, like the Santa Fe tragedy that killed nine children, and advocacy groups are important for raising political attention and creating an opportunity for legislative reform. It highlights the importance of policy entrepreneurs who used the opportunity to push through new legislation. Though the political dynamic was predominantly local, international actors worked with local advocates to build demand for safety and develop solutions that could be deployed when the opportunity arose. Most important, the case emphasizes the importance of developing institutions with the resources and authority necessary for managing national road safety programs.
交通伤害仍然是大多数中低收入国家(LMICs)的主要健康问题。然而,大多数 LMICs 尚未建立具有立法授权和必要财政资源的机构,以协调大规模干预措施。阿根廷提供了一个反例。阿根廷是一个联邦国家,将权力下放给省政府是有效国家干预的主要障碍。2008 年,阿根廷通过了一项法律,设立了一个国家道路安全机构,并随后获得世界银行贷款,以建立该机构协调行动的能力。尽管阿根廷的交通伤害尚未开始下降,但这些事态发展提出了重要问题:我们使用阿根廷的描述性案例研究(单一案例、整体设计)来探讨这些问题。该案例表明,关注事件,如造成 9 名儿童死亡的圣达菲悲剧,以及倡导团体,对于引起政治关注和为立法改革创造机会非常重要。它强调了政策企业家的重要性,他们利用这个机会推动新立法的通过。尽管政治动态主要是地方性的,但国际行为体与当地的倡导者合作,为安全需求创造了需求,并制定了在机会出现时可以实施的解决方案。最重要的是,该案例强调了发展具有管理国家道路安全计划所需资源和权力的机构的重要性。