Colella Mariel, Bisanzo Mark, Farquhar Carey, Nambaziira Rashidah, Carter Elizabeth, Gimbel Sarah, O'Malley Gabrielle
Global Emergency Care, Vermont, USA.
University of Washington, 325 9th Avenue, Seattle, WA 98104, USA.
Afr J Emerg Med. 2019 Mar;9(1):25-29. doi: 10.1016/j.afjem.2018.12.002. Epub 2019 Feb 6.
Leadership and teaching skills are essential, but not often emphasized, components of medical training. As emergency care develops as a specialty in Uganda, two cadres of providers are being trained: physicians and non-physician clinicians (NPCs). Building formal leadership and educator training into these curricula is essential.
A week long continuing education (CE) course on leadership and teaching is described and evaluated for effectiveness using Kirkpatrick's framework for learner-centred outcomes. The emergency care trained NPCs participated in a week-long course consisting of lectures, role-playing, and small group discussions, as well as a personality self-assessment. The evaluation process consisted of: 1) an immediate post-course survey to measure learner satisfaction, 2) a retrospective, pre/post self-assessment with a Likert-type scoring tool to measure knowledge gains, and 3) a three-month follow up survey and structured interviews to measure knowledge retention and behaviour change in practice.
All 15 NPCs participated in the evaluation process. Learner satisfaction was high with an average score of 9.3 (on a 1-10 scale) for course content, amount learned, and use of time. Participants reported gains in knowledge for each of the 24 competencies measured, with an average difference in pre- and post-course Likert scores of 1.11 (on a scale of 1-5). Lastly, all 15 participants shared detailed examples of using course content in practice three months after the course finished. The most frequently mentioned themes were "giving and receiving feedback," "delegating and assigning tasks," and "communication."
This course was a successful CE intervention in this setting as measured by Kirkpatrick's framework. The most frequently mentioned concepts used in practice point to the NPCs ability to take on leadership roles in this setting. Further research and evaluation methods should focus on the influence of culture and personalities on leadership education and translation into practice in an EM setting.
领导力和教学技能是医学培训中必不可少但却常常未被强调的组成部分。随着乌干达将急诊护理发展成为一个专业领域,正在培训两类医疗服务提供者:医生和非医生临床医生(NPC)。将正式的领导力和教育者培训纳入这些课程至关重要。
描述了一个为期一周的关于领导力和教学的继续教育(CE)课程,并使用柯克帕特里克以学习者为中心的成果框架对其有效性进行评估。接受过急诊护理培训的NPC参加了一个为期一周的课程,该课程包括讲座、角色扮演和小组讨论,以及一次个性自我评估。评估过程包括:1)课程结束后立即进行的调查,以衡量学习者的满意度;2)使用李克特式评分工具进行回顾性的课前/课后自我评估,以衡量知识收获;3)为期三个月的随访调查和结构化访谈,以衡量知识保留情况以及实践中的行为变化。
所有15名NPC都参与了评估过程。学习者满意度很高,课程内容、所学内容和时间利用方面的平均得分是9.3(满分10分)。参与者报告称,在所测量的24项能力中,每项能力的知识都有增长,课前和课后李克特评分的平均差异为1.11(满分1-5分)。最后,所有15名参与者都分享了课程结束三个月后在实践中使用课程内容的详细例子。最常提到的主题是“给予和接受反馈”、“分配和委派任务”以及“沟通”。
按照柯克帕特里克的框架衡量,本课程在这种情况下是一次成功的CE干预。实践中最常提到的概念表明NPC有能力在这种情况下承担领导角色。进一步的研究和评估方法应关注文化和个性对领导力教育的影响以及在急诊环境中转化为实践的情况。