Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK.
University of Central Lancashire, Preston, UK.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2019 Aug;28(4):845-856. doi: 10.1111/inm.12577. Epub 2019 Mar 18.
International efforts to minimize coercive practices include the US Six Core Strategies© (6CS). This innovative approach has limited evidence of its effectiveness, with few robustly designed studies, and has not been formally implemented or evaluated in the UK. An adapted version of the 6CS, which we called 'REsTRAIN Yourself' (RY), was devised to suit the UK context and evaluated using mixed methods. RY aimed to reduce the use of physical restraint in mental health inpatient ward settings through training and practice development with whole teams, directly in the ward settings where change was to be implemented and barriers to change overcome. In this paper, we present qualitative findings that report on staff perspectives of the impact and value of RY following its implementation. Thirty-six staff participated in semi-structured interviews with data subject to thematic analysis. Eight themes are reported that highlight perceived improvements in every domain of the 6CS after RY had been introduced. Staff reported more positively on their relationships with service users and felt their attitudes towards the use of coercive practices such as restraint were changed; the service as a whole shifted in terms of restraint awareness and reduction; and new policies, procedures, and language were introduced despite certain barriers. These findings need to be appreciated in a context wherein substantial reductions in the use of physical restraint were proven possible, largely due to building upon empathic and relational alternatives. However, yet more could be achieved with greater resourcing of inpatient care.
国际社会努力将强制性做法最小化,包括美国的六项核心策略©(6CS)。这种创新方法的有效性证据有限,很少有经过严格设计的研究,并且尚未在英国正式实施或评估。我们对 6CS 进行了改编,称之为“自我约束”(RY),以适应英国的情况,并使用混合方法进行了评估。RY 的目的是通过对整个团队进行培训和实践发展,减少精神科住院病房环境中身体约束的使用,直接在需要实施变革和克服变革障碍的病房环境中进行。在本文中,我们提出了定性研究结果,报告了 RY 实施后工作人员对其影响和价值的看法。36 名工作人员参加了半结构化访谈,访谈数据经过主题分析。报告了八个主题,突出了 RY 引入后 6CS 的每个领域都有了明显的改善。工作人员对他们与服务使用者的关系的评价更为积极,并认为他们对诸如约束等强制性做法的态度发生了变化;整个服务在约束意识和减少方面都有所转变;尽管存在某些障碍,但仍引入了新的政策、程序和语言。这些发现需要在一个证明可以大大减少身体约束使用的背景下得到理解,这主要是因为建立在同理心和关系替代的基础上。然而,若为住院护理提供更多资源,还可以取得更大的成果。