Kafka Rene M, Aveytua Ian L, Choi Paul J, DiLandro Anthony C, Tubbs R Shane, Loukas Marios, Mintz Douglas N, Baidya Ritwik, Kumar Sushil, Sangari Santosh K, Mtui Estomih P, D'Antoni Anthony V
Podiatry, Eastern Colorado Health Care System, Denver, USA.
Podiatry, Memorial Health System, Marietta, USA.
Cureus. 2019 Jan 8;11(1):e3847. doi: 10.7759/cureus.3847.
Introduction Lateral ankle sprain caused by forcible plantar flexion and inversion of the foot commonly damages the anterior talofibular ligament and other ligaments. Unfortunately, involvement of the bifurcate ligament (BL) is often overlooked when assessing such injuries in clinical practice and identification of this ligament on magnetic resonance (MR) scans can be challenging. Anatomically, the BL is a Y-shaped structure with two bands: the calcaneonavicular ligament (CNL) and calcaneocuboid ligament (CCL). There are few anatomical studies on the morphometric characteristics of the BL and even fewer biomechanical studies. Therefore, the objective of this anatomico-radiological study was to investigate the morphology of the BL using a multifaceted approach, and classify the fiber characteristics of the CNL and CCL. Materials and methods We measured the length and the width of 53 embalmed cadaveric feet. Meticulous dissection of each foot was performed to expose the BL. Measurements of the length, width, thickness, and shape of the CNL and CCL were taken using a digital caliper. We also documented the fiber orientation of each ligament, and used a goniometer to measure the bifurcation angle between the CNL and CCL via two methods. Confirmatory histologic analysis of the ligaments was performed and digital radiographs of the ligaments with attached radiopaque monofilament were taken. We also included an MR scan of the BL. Using descriptive and inferential statistics, we documented any significant relationships between the variables. Results Mean (range) age at death of cadavers was 76 (42-94) years. The CNL was found in all the feet and the CCL was not present in 9.4% of the feet. Mean (standard deviation) length of the CNL and CCL was 22.7 (4.12) mm and 10.9 (2.53) mm, respectively. Mean (standard deviation) thickness of the CNL and CCL was 3.23 (1.56) mm and 1.48 (0.71) mm, respectively. Related to ligament morphology, the CNL was most frequently cord shaped (67.92%) and the CCL was most frequently flat shaped (83.33%). The mean bifurcation angle measured 32.75and 29.31in methods 1 and 2, respectively. The correlation between the two measured angles was very strong ( < 0.001). Discussion We found that 90.6% of feet had both the CNL and CCL, 9.4% had the CNL and no CCL, and none (0%) had the CCL and no CNL. These frequencies are similar to a recent Japanese study. Our sample of donors were American and predominantly white. Whether the difference in frequencies between the studies is related to ethnicity is unknown and requires future investigation. Interestingly, on average the CNLs were twice as long and twice as thick as the CCLs. The CCLs tended to be wider distally and tapered compared to the CNLs. Conclusions Our findings better classify the morphology and fiber orientation of the BL. Coupled with the radiographs and MR scan, our data may be of particular value to radiologists and surgeons. Our BL fiber orientation classification system and angle measurements can pave the way for future biomechanical studies to investigate any relationships between fiber type, angle, and strength of the constituent bands. More accurate descriptions of the BL should lead to improved diagnosis and treatment of ligamentous injuries of the foot.
引言 足部强力跖屈和内翻导致的外侧踝关节扭伤通常会损伤距腓前韧带和其他韧带。不幸的是,在临床实践中评估此类损伤时,常常忽略了分歧韧带(BL)的累及情况,并且在磁共振(MR)扫描中识别该韧带可能具有挑战性。从解剖学上讲,BL是一种Y形结构,有两条束带:跟舟韧带(CNL)和跟骰韧带(CCL)。关于BL形态学特征的解剖学研究很少,生物力学研究更是少之又少。因此,本解剖放射学研究的目的是采用多方面方法研究BL的形态,并对CNL和CCL的纤维特征进行分类。
材料与方法 我们测量了53只防腐尸体足的长度和宽度。对每只足进行细致解剖以暴露BL。使用数字卡尺测量CNL和CCL的长度、宽度、厚度和形状。我们还记录了每条韧带的纤维方向,并使用测角仪通过两种方法测量CNL和CCL之间的分叉角度。对韧带进行了验证性组织学分析,并拍摄了附着不透射线单丝的韧带的数字X线片。我们还纳入了BL的MR扫描。使用描述性和推断性统计,我们记录了变量之间的任何显著关系。
结果 尸体的平均(范围)死亡年龄为76(42 - 94)岁。在所有足中均发现了CNL,9.4%的足中未发现CCL。CNL和CCL的平均(标准差)长度分别为22.7(4.12)mm和10.9(2.53)mm。CNL和CCL的平均(标准差)厚度分别为3.23(1.56)mm和1.48(0.71)mm。关于韧带形态,CNL最常见的形状是索状(67.92%),CCL最常见的形状是扁平状(83.33%)。方法1和方法2测量的平均分叉角度分别为32.75°和29.31°。两种测量角度之间的相关性非常强(<0.001)。
讨论 我们发现90.6%的足同时有CNL和CCL,9.4%的足有CNL但没有CCL,没有(0%)足有CCL但没有CNL。这些频率与最近一项日本研究相似。我们的捐赠者样本是美国人,且主要是白人。两项研究之间频率的差异是否与种族有关尚不清楚,需要未来进一步研究。有趣的是,平均而言,CNL的长度和厚度是CCL的两倍。与CNL相比,CCL在远端往往更宽且呈锥形。
结论 我们的研究结果更好地对BL的形态和纤维方向进行了分类。结合X线片和MR扫描,我们的数据可能对放射科医生和外科医生具有特殊价值。我们的BL纤维方向分类系统和角度测量可为未来的生物力学研究铺平道路,以研究纤维类型、角度和组成束带强度之间的任何关系。对BL更准确的描述应能改善足部韧带损伤的诊断和治疗。