Maehler Claudia, Joerns Christina, Schuchardt Kirsten
Department of Educational Psychology, Institute of Psychology, Universitätsplatz 1, 31141 Hildesheim, Germany.
Children (Basel). 2019 Mar 20;6(3):47. doi: 10.3390/children6030047.
For the future school performance of a child in the fields of literacy and numeracy, the operational efficiency of working memory is a central predictor. Children affected by dyslexia exhibit specific deficits in the functions of working memory. A software application for elementary school-age children has been specifically developed for this study, attempting to improve the working memory's operational efficiency. Based on Baddeley's model of working memory (1986), the phonological loop, the visuo-spatial sketchpad, and the central executive were trained in 18 sessions over a period of six weeks. The group of test subjects undergoing this training was composed of third-graders, of which 43 were and 27 were not affected by dyslexia. The untrained control group was made up of 41 third-graders with dyslexia and 28 without dyslexia. While the short-term effects of the program could not be proven, the present analyses focus on long-term effects. The results obtained from a pre-test/follow-up design reveal that no long-term increases in performance regarding phonological and central executive working memory could be confirmed. Only the visuo-spatial Corsi block span exhibited a training effect over a period of three months. Additionally, training did not show any long-term effect of performance improvement, not even for a subgroup of children with dyslexia and an especially low working memory performance. Thus, even after this study, the question whether working memory can be trained or not remains partly unanswered but leaves us predominantly pessimistic.
对于孩子未来在读写和算术领域的学业表现而言,工作记忆的运作效率是一个核心预测指标。受诵读困难影响的儿童在工作记忆功能方面表现出特定缺陷。本研究专门为小学适龄儿童开发了一款软件应用程序,试图提高工作记忆的运作效率。基于巴德利(1986年)的工作记忆模型,语音回路、视觉空间画板和中央执行系统在六周内进行了18次训练。接受该训练的测试对象组由三年级学生组成,其中43名受诵读困难影响,27名未受影响。未经训练的对照组由41名患有诵读困难的三年级学生和28名未患诵读困难的三年级学生组成。虽然该项目的短期效果无法得到证实,但目前的分析集中在长期效果上。从前测/随访设计获得的结果显示,在语音和中央执行工作记忆方面,无法确认长期的表现提升。只有视觉空间的科西积木跨度在三个月的时间里呈现出训练效果。此外,训练并未显示出任何长期的表现改善效果,即使是对于患有诵读困难且工作记忆表现特别低的儿童亚组也是如此。因此,即使在这项研究之后,工作记忆是否可以训练的问题仍部分未得到解答,但总体上让我们感到悲观。