Moore Amy Lawson, Miller Terissa M, Moore Jeffrey J, Ledbetter Christina
Department of Psychology, Gibson Institute of Cognitive Research, Colorado Springs, CO, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, Louisiana State University Health, Shreveport, LA, USA.
Psychol Res Behav Manag. 2023 Apr 17;16:1195-1220. doi: 10.2147/PRBM.S397665. eCollection 2023.
The state of reading proficiency among children in the United States continues to be a subject of concern among psychologists, teachers, parents, policy makers, and the education community at large. Despite the widespread use of curricular methods that teach basic reading skills, there remains a large percentage of children that struggle to read. Therefore, novel approaches to reading remediation should be explored.
The aims of this study were to examine 1) the effect of a multicomponent cognitive and reading intervention on cognitive and reading skills; 2) the role of ADHD, age, sex, IQ score, and individual cognitive skills on the effectiveness of the ReadRx intervention; and 3) parent-reported behavioral outcomes following the ReadRx intervention.
The current study analyzed a large real-world dataset to examine cognitive, reading, and behavioral outcomes for struggling readers (n = 3527) who had completed 24 weeks (120 hours) of intense cognitive training integrated with a structured literacy intervention using ReadRx in a one-on-one clinic setting.
Analyses of pretest and post-test scores showed statistically significant changes on all cognitive and reading measures including attention, visual processing, processing speed, long-term memory, working memory, reasoning, phonological awareness, Work Attack, phonetic coding, spelling, comprehension, and overall IQ score with medium to very large effect sizes. The results included an average 4.1-year gain in reading skills including a 6-year gain in phonological awareness. No differences were found based on age, sex, or ADHD status, and minimal differences were found based on pre-intervention IQ score and cognitive test scores. The study also included a qualitative thematic analysis of parent-reported behavioral outcomes revealing themes of improved cognition, academic performance, and psychosocial skills including confidence and perseverance.
Our findings were consistent with previous controlled studies on this intervention and offer an encouraging alternative instructional approach to reading remediation that aligns with the Science of Reading and includes intensive remediation of underlying cognitive skills.
美国儿童的阅读能力状况一直是心理学家、教师、家长、政策制定者以及整个教育界关注的话题。尽管广泛采用了教授基本阅读技能的课程方法,但仍有很大比例的儿童在阅读方面存在困难。因此,应探索新的阅读补救方法。
本研究的目的是检验:1)多成分认知与阅读干预对认知和阅读技能的影响;2)注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)、年龄、性别、智商分数和个体认知技能在ReadRx干预效果中的作用;3)ReadRx干预后家长报告的行为结果。
本研究分析了一个大型的真实世界数据集,以检验在一对一诊所环境中完成了24周(120小时)强化认知训练并结合使用ReadRx进行结构化读写干预的阅读困难儿童(n = 3527)的认知、阅读和行为结果。
对前测和后测分数的分析表明,在所有认知和阅读指标上都有统计学上的显著变化,包括注意力、视觉处理、处理速度、长期记忆、工作记忆、推理、语音意识、单词攻击、语音编码、拼写、理解和总体智商分数,效应大小为中等至非常大。结果包括阅读技能平均提高4.1年,其中语音意识提高6年。未发现基于年龄、性别或ADHD状态的差异,基于干预前智商分数和认知测试分数的差异极小。该研究还对家长报告的行为结果进行了定性主题分析,揭示了认知、学业成绩和心理社会技能改善的主题,包括自信心和毅力。
我们的研究结果与之前关于该干预的对照研究一致,并提供了一种令人鼓舞的替代阅读补救教学方法,该方法与阅读科学相一致,包括对潜在认知技能的强化补救。