Department of Bioscience, School of Science and Technology, Kwansei Gakuin University, Hyogo 669-1337, Japan.
National Institute of Technology, Hakodate College, Hokkaido 042-8501, Japan.
eNeuro. 2019 Mar 20;6(1). doi: 10.1523/ENEURO.0395-18.2019. eCollection 2019 Jan-Feb.
Despite the profound influence on coding capacity of sensory neurons, the measurements of noise correlations have been inconsistent. This is, possibly, because nonstationarity, i.e., drifting baselines, engendered the spurious long-term correlations even if no actual short-term correlation existed. Although attempts to separate them have been made previously, they were for specific cases or computationally too demanding. Here we proposed an information-geometric method to unbiasedly estimate pure short-term noise correlations irrespective of the background brain activities without demanding computational resources. First, the benchmark simulations demonstrated that the proposed estimator is more accurate and computationally efficient than the conventional correlograms and the residual correlations with Kalman filters or moving averages of length three or more, while the best moving average of length two coincided with the propose method regarding correlation estimates. Next, we analyzed the cat V1 neural responses to demonstrate that the statistical test accompanying the proposed method combined with the existing nonstationarity test enabled us to dissociate short-term and long-term noise correlations. When we excluded the spurious noise correlations of purely long-term nature, only a small fraction of neuron pairs showed significant short-term correlations, possibly reconciling the previous inconsistent observations on existence of significant noise correlations. The decoding accuracy was slightly improved by the short-term correlations. Although the long-term correlations deteriorated the generalizability, the generalizability was recovered by the decoder with trend removal, suggesting that brains could overcome nonstationarity. Thus, the proposed method enables us to elucidate the impacts of short-term and long-term noise correlations in a dissociated manner.
尽管感觉神经元的编码能力受到了深远的影响,但噪声相关性的测量结果并不一致。这可能是因为非平稳性,即漂移的基线,即使实际上没有短期相关性存在,也会产生虚假的长期相关性。虽然以前已经尝试对它们进行分离,但它们针对的是特定情况或计算要求过高。在这里,我们提出了一种信息几何方法,可以在不要求计算资源的情况下,公正地估计纯净的短期噪声相关性,而不受背景大脑活动的影响。首先,基准模拟表明,与传统的相关图以及使用卡尔曼滤波器或长度为三或更长的移动平均值的剩余相关性相比,所提出的估计器更准确且计算效率更高,而长度为二的最佳移动平均值在相关性估计方面与提出的方法一致。接下来,我们分析了猫的 V1 神经反应,以证明所提出的方法结合现有的非平稳性测试,可以分离短期和长期噪声相关性。当我们排除了纯粹长期性质的虚假噪声相关性时,只有一小部分神经元对显示出显著的短期相关性,这可能调和了以前关于存在显著噪声相关性的不一致观察。短期相关性略微提高了解码精度。虽然长期相关性会降低泛化能力,但通过去除趋势的解码器可以恢复泛化能力,这表明大脑可以克服非平稳性。因此,所提出的方法使我们能够以分离的方式阐明短期和长期噪声相关性的影响。