Hutchison Alana R, Cartmill Bena, Wall Laurelie R, Ward Elizabeth C, Hargrave Catriona, Brown Elizabeth
Division of Speech Pathology, School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, the University of Queensland, St Lucia, Queensland, Australia.
Centre for Functioning and Health Research, Queensland Health, Level 3, Centro Buranda, Buranda, Queensland, Australia.
J Med Radiat Sci. 2019 Jun;66(2):103-111. doi: 10.1002/jmrs.332. Epub 2019 Apr 4.
This study examined knowledge and practices of speech pathologists (SPs) and radiation therapists (RTs) regarding plan optimisation for head and neck cancer (HNC) patients, and the potential impacts on swallowing function. The secondary aim was to explore the level of interaction occurring between these professional groups within cancer centres.
Two electronic surveys, with matched questions for SPs and RTs, explored: service/institutional demographics; clinician awareness, practices regarding plan optimisation to swallowing structures and; relationships and interactions between SPs and RTs in the management of HNC patients. Participant recruitment occurred through specialist professional networks with additional snowball sampling. Data were analysed with descriptive statistics and thematic analysis.
A total of 32 SPs and 41 RTs completed surveys. All SPs and 50% of RTs were aware of dose-dysphagia relationships, though SPs rarely used dosimetric information to inform patient management. Only 33% of RTs indicated that their centres actively constrain dose to swallowing structures, reporting that staffing skill mixtures and lack of prescription by the treating RO were restrictive factors. Both SPs and RTs acknowledged the importance of collaborating with colleagues (SPs/RTs) and felt they could assist their colleagues in devising patient management plans, though current collaboration/interaction was minimal.
Levels of awareness were found to be higher in SP group. Despite high levels of awareness, limited use of swallowing structure dose constraints and hence dosimetric information specific to swallowing was rarely used to optimise/guide multidisciplinary HNC acute care. Opportunities for enhanced collaboration between SPs and RTs should be considered.
本研究调查了言语病理学家(SPs)和放射治疗师(RTs)在头颈部癌(HNC)患者计划优化方面的知识和实践,以及对吞咽功能的潜在影响。次要目的是探讨癌症中心内这些专业群体之间的互动程度。
针对SPs和RTs设计了两份匹配问题的电子调查问卷,内容包括:服务/机构人口统计学;临床医生对吞咽结构计划优化的认识、实践,以及SPs和RTs在HNC患者管理中的关系与互动。通过专业网络招募参与者,并采用滚雪球抽样法。对数据进行描述性统计和主题分析。
共有32名SPs和41名RTs完成了调查。所有SPs和50%的RTs了解剂量与吞咽困难的关系,不过SPs很少使用剂量学信息来指导患者管理。只有33%的RTs表示他们的中心积极限制对吞咽结构的剂量,称人员技能组合和治疗放疗科医生缺乏处方是限制因素。SPs和RTs都承认与同事(SPs/RTs)合作的重要性,并认为他们可以在制定患者管理计划方面帮助同事,尽管目前的合作/互动很少。
发现SP组的认知水平较高。尽管认知水平较高,但吞咽结构剂量限制的使用有限,因此很少使用特定于吞咽的剂量学信息来优化/指导多学科HNC急性护理。应考虑增加SPs和RTs之间合作的机会。