Department of Special Needs Education, University of Oslo, Norway.
Solberg School, Akershus County, Norway.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2019 Jan 30;62(1):153-168. doi: 10.1044/2018_JSLHR-L-17-0087.
Purpose We sought to estimate the prevalence of isolated epileptiform activity (IEA) in children with speech and language impairments and discuss the utility of an electroencephalogram (EEG) in assessing these children. Method We conducted a systematic review and searched for eligible studies in 8 databases. All languages were included, and meta-analyses were performed. Results We found 55 prevalence estimates (8 with control group). The odds of having IEA were 6 times greater for children with speech and language impairments than for typically developing children. The overall pooled prevalence of IEA was 27.3%. A wide variation between the prevalence estimates was, to a certain degree, explained by type of impairment (8.1% in speech impairments, 25.8% in language impairments, and 51.5% in language regression). Sleep EEGs detected a significantly higher prevalence than awake EEGs. Although the presence of epilepsy gave a significantly higher prevalence than if epilepsy was not present, 33.5% of children with language impairment but without epilepsy were found to have IEA in sleep EEGs. Conclusions This systematic review shows that IEA is 6 times more prevalent in children with speech and language impairment than in typically developing children. However, the prevalence rates vary to a great extent. Uncovering IEA will, in addition to information from other clinical assessments, provide a more comprehensive understanding of the child's impairments. We argue that, although EEG is of questionable value when assessing children with speech impairments, sleep EEG could be valuable when assessing children with language impairments and, in particular, children who experience language regression.
目的 我们旨在评估言语和语言障碍儿童中孤立性癫痫样活动(IEA)的患病率,并讨论脑电图(EEG)在评估这些儿童中的作用。
方法 我们进行了系统评价,并在 8 个数据库中搜索了符合条件的研究。纳入了所有语言的研究,并进行了荟萃分析。
结果 我们找到了 55 项患病率估计值(其中 8 项有对照组)。言语和语言障碍儿童出现 IEA 的几率是正常发育儿童的 6 倍。IEA 的总体汇总患病率为 27.3%。患病率估计值之间存在很大差异,在一定程度上可以通过障碍类型来解释(言语障碍为 8.1%,语言障碍为 25.8%,语言退行性疾病为 51.5%)。睡眠 EEG 比清醒 EEG 检测到的 IEA 患病率更高。尽管存在癫痫的儿童比不存在癫痫的儿童的患病率显著更高,但在睡眠 EEG 中发现 33.5%的语言障碍但无癫痫的儿童存在 IEA。
结论 本系统评价表明,言语和语言障碍儿童的 IEA 患病率是正常发育儿童的 6 倍。然而,患病率差异很大。除了来自其他临床评估的信息外,发现 IEA 将为儿童的障碍提供更全面的理解。我们认为,尽管 EEG 在评估言语障碍儿童时价值存疑,但在评估语言障碍儿童,特别是经历语言退行性疾病的儿童时,睡眠 EEG 可能具有价值。