Shibamoto Y, Yukawa Y, Tsutsui K, Takahashi M, Abe M
Jpn J Cancer Res. 1986 Sep;77(9):908-15.
Radiobiologically hypoxic fractions of 4 experimental tumors (RIF1, B16, EMT6/KU, SCCVII) of various sizes implanted subcutaneously (sc) or intradermally (id) were compared under identical conditions by using the paired survival curve assay method. The two survival curves for tumors in air-breathing and asphyxiated mice were almost parallel for EMT6/KU and SCCVII tumors, but not for RIF1 and B16 tumors. Therefore, hypoxic fractions were estimated by fitting the best parallel lines to the two sets of survival data. The values for 10 mm-diameter sc tumors in the hind legs of syngeneic mice were 4.7% for RIF1, 4.5% for B16, 14% for EMT6/KU, and 8.5% for SCCVII. The variation of the values is quite small in spite of the variety of biological characteristics of these tumors. Histological examination revealed that EMT6/KU and B16 tumors contained large necrotic areas, while SCCVII and RIF1 had small areas of necrosis. Thus, the hypoxic fraction and the proportion of necrosis in the histological specimens were not clearly correlated. The values for 6 mm and 16 mm sc EMT6/KU tumors were 5.9 and 22%, respectively, while that for 6 mm id tumors was 16%. The values for 5 mm and 18 mm sc SCCVII tumors were 0.86 and 8.4%, respectively. These results indicated that: (1) id EMT6/KU tumors had a higher hypoxic fraction than sc ones of the same size; (2) the hypoxic fraction increased with increase in tumor size in EMT6/KU tumors, while it reached a plateau at a certain size in SCVII tumors.
采用配对生存曲线分析法,在相同条件下比较了皮下(sc)或皮内(id)植入的4种不同大小实验性肿瘤(RIF1、B16、EMT6/KU、SCCVII)的放射生物学缺氧分数。对于EMT6/KU和SCCVII肿瘤,呼吸空气和窒息小鼠体内肿瘤的两条生存曲线几乎平行,但RIF1和B16肿瘤并非如此。因此,通过将最佳平行线拟合到两组生存数据来估计缺氧分数。同基因小鼠后腿直径10mm的皮下肿瘤,RIF1为4.7%,B16为4.5%,EMT6/KU为14%,SCCVII为8.5%。尽管这些肿瘤具有多种生物学特性,但这些值的变化相当小。组织学检查显示,EMT6/KU和B16肿瘤含有大片坏死区域,而SCCVII和RIF1的坏死区域较小。因此,组织学标本中的缺氧分数与坏死比例并无明显相关性。6mm和16mm皮下EMT6/KU肿瘤的值分别为5.9%和22%,而6mm皮内肿瘤的值为16%。5mm和18mm皮下SCCVII肿瘤的值分别为0.86%和8.4%。这些结果表明:(1)相同大小的皮内EMT6/KU肿瘤比皮下肿瘤具有更高的缺氧分数;(2)EMT6/KU肿瘤的缺氧分数随肿瘤大小增加而升高,而SCCVII肿瘤在一定大小后达到平台期。