Health Management and Economics Research Center, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Health Services Management, School of Health Management and Information Sciences, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2019 Apr 16;17(1):42. doi: 10.1186/s12961-019-0442-1.
Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is a major public health challenge worldwide. Implementing policies to cope with this challenge requires commitment from all stakeholders at various levels, and all necessary resources should be mobilised. Support for various HCV-related stakeholders can reduce the challenges and obstacles that can be encountered during the programme implementation. The present study aims to identify all stakeholders involved with HCV-related policy-making in Iran at different steps (policy development, implementation and evaluation) and to characterise them in terms of interest, position, power and influence, in order to provide valuable information for appropriate decision-making and design. The present study can also serve as a case study for healthcare systems in other countries.
An approach based on social network analysis was utilised. Data collected included relevant document searches and in-depth interviews to a sample of 18 key informants.
Various stakeholders were found to be involved with HCV-related policies in Iran. The extent of their participation and support in policy-making varied. Specifically, international agencies had a high interest for HCV-related policy-making, whereas media and members of the private sector were characterised by a medium interest and governmental and non-governmental bodies by a highly variable interest, ranging from low to high, depending on the specific organism. Moreover, media and members of the private sector, non-governmental institutions and international agencies were rated low in terms of position, whereas governmental actors were rated low to high. Media were rated medium in terms of power, whereas international agencies and members of the private sector were respectively rated low to medium and low. Non-governmental actors were rated low, whilst governmental bodies were rated low to high. Finally, media, members of the private sector and international agencies were rated medium in terms of influence, whereas non-governmental and governmental actors were respectively rated low to medium and low to high.
Policy-making involves trust, negotiation and integration of the different views of all stakeholders. Social network analysis was critical for identifying stakeholders and showing that, in Iran, involvement in HCV-related policy-making is generally low. This information is of practical implication for policy- and decision-makers regarding the adoption of more favourable and effective strategies.
丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)感染是全球范围内的一个主要公共卫生挑战。实施应对这一挑战的政策需要各级各利益相关方共同承诺,并调动所有必要资源。为与 HCV 相关的各利益相关方提供支持,可以减少方案实施过程中可能遇到的挑战和障碍。本研究旨在确定伊朗在不同步骤(政策制定、实施和评估)中与 HCV 相关政策制定有关的所有利益相关方,并根据其利益、立场、权力和影响力对其进行描述,以便为制定适当的决策和设计提供有价值的信息。本研究也可以作为其他国家医疗保健系统的案例研究。
采用基于社会网络分析的方法。数据收集包括对 18 名关键知情者样本的相关文件搜索和深入访谈。
在伊朗,发现有各种利益相关方参与 HCV 相关政策的制定。他们在决策中的参与程度和支持力度各不相同。具体而言,国际机构对 HCV 相关政策制定有浓厚的兴趣,而媒体和私营部门成员的兴趣则处于中等水平,政府和非政府机构的兴趣则高低不一,具体取决于特定的机构。此外,媒体和私营部门成员、非政府机构和国际机构在地位方面的评级较低,而政府行为体的评级则从低到高。媒体在权力方面的评级为中等,而国际机构和私营部门成员的评级分别为低到中等和低。非政府行为体的评级较低,而政府机构的评级则从低到高。最后,媒体、私营部门成员和国际机构在影响力方面的评级为中等,而非政府和政府机构的评级则分别为低到中等和低到高。
决策制定涉及信任、协商和整合所有利益相关方的不同观点。社会网络分析对于确定利益相关方至关重要,并表明在伊朗,参与 HCV 相关政策制定的程度普遍较低。这些信息对于政策制定者和决策者在采取更有利和有效的策略方面具有实际意义。