Department of Humanities, Social and Political Sciences, ETH Zürich, Weinbergstrasse 109, 8092, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Electrical Engineering and Information Technology, ETH Zürich, Sternwartstrasse 7, Zurich, 8092, Switzerland.
Behav Res Methods. 2019 Oct;51(5):2120-2138. doi: 10.3758/s13428-018-1180-y.
Face-to-face interactions are important for a variety of individual behaviors and outcomes. In recent years, a number of human sensor technologies have been proposed to incorporate direct observations in behavioral studies of face-to-face interactions. One of the most promising emerging technologies is the application of active Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) badges. They are increasingly applied in behavioral studies because of their low costs, straightforward applicability, and moderate ethical concerns. However, despite the attention that RFID badges have recently received, there is a lack of systematic tests on how valid RFID badges are in measuring face-to-face interactions. With two studies, we aim to fill this gap. Study 1 (N = 11) compares how data assessed with RFID badges correspond with video data of the same interactions (construct validity) and how this fit can be improved using straightforward data processing strategies. The analyses show that the RFID badges have a sensitivity of 50%, which can be enhanced to 65% when flickering signals with gaps of less than 75 s are interpolated. The specificity is relatively less affected by this interpolation process (before interpolation 97%, after interpolation 94.7%)-resulting in an improved accuracy of the measurement. In Study 2 (N = 73) we show that self-report data of social interactions correspond highly with data gathered with the RFID badges (criterion validity).
面对面的互动对于各种个体行为和结果都很重要。近年来,许多人类传感器技术被提出,将直接观察纳入面对面互动的行为研究中。最有前途的新兴技术之一是应用主动射频识别 (RFID) 徽章。由于其低成本、简单易用和适度的伦理问题,它们在行为研究中得到了越来越多的应用。然而,尽管最近 RFID 徽章受到了关注,但对于它们在测量面对面互动方面的有效性还缺乏系统的测试。我们通过两项研究来填补这一空白。研究 1(N=11)比较了使用 RFID 徽章评估的数据与同一互动的视频数据之间的对应关系(构念效度),以及使用简单的数据处理策略如何提高这种对应关系。分析表明,RFID 徽章的灵敏度为 50%,当插入间隔小于 75 秒的闪烁信号时,灵敏度可提高到 65%。特异性受此插值过程的影响相对较小(插值前为 97%,插值后为 94.7%),从而提高了测量的准确性。在研究 2(N=73)中,我们表明社交互动的自我报告数据与使用 RFID 徽章收集的数据高度相关(效标效度)。