Chemical footprinting and kinetic assays reveal dual functions for highly conserved eukaryotic tRNA guanylyltransferase residues.

tRNA guanylyltransferase (Thg1) adds a single guanine to the -1 position of tRNA as part of its maturation. This seemingly modest addition of one nucleotide to tRNA ensures translational fidelity by providing a critical identity element for the histidyl aminoacyl tRNA synthetase (HisRS). Like HisRS, Thg1 utilizes the GUG anticodon for selective tRNA recognition, and Thg1-tRNA complex structures have revealed conserved residues that interact with anticodon nucleotides. Separately, kinetic analysis of alanine variants has demonstrated that many of these same residues are required for catalytic activity. A model in which loss of activity with the variants was attributed directly to loss of the critical anticodon interaction has been proposed to explain the combined biochemical and structural results. Here we used RNA chemical footprinting and binding assays to test this model and further probe the molecular basis for the requirement for two critical tRNA-interacting residues, His-152 and Lys-187, in the context of human Thg1 (hThg1). Surprisingly, we found that His-152 and Lys-187 alanine-substituted variants maintain a similar overall interaction with the anticodon region, arguing against the sufficiency of this interaction for driving catalysis. Instead, conservative mutagenesis revealed a new direct function for these residues in recognition of a non-Watson-Crick G:A bp, which had not been described previously. These results have important implications for the evolution of eukaryotic Thg1 from a family of ancestral promiscuous RNA repair enzymes to the highly selective enzymes needed for their essential function in tRNA maturation.