Dias Raylene, Dave Nandini, Agrawal Barkha, Baghele Aarti
Department of Paediatric Anaesthesiology, Seth GS Medical College and KEM Hospital, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Indian J Anaesth. 2019 Apr;63(4):277-283. doi: 10.4103/ija.IJA_653_18.
Measurement of end-tidal anaesthetic gas concentrations (ETAG) is currently a pragmatic indicator for monitoring anaesthetic depth. We aimed to assess the performance of ETAG for sevoflurane (ETAG-sevo) with bispectral index (BIS) and difference between inspired and end-tidal oxygen concentration (Fi-Et)O% in measuring anaesthetic depth in toddlers and preschool children. Primary outcome was to correlate BIS with ETAG-sevo. Secondary outcome was to correlate (Fi-Et)O% with ETAG-sevo and to derive cut-off value of (Fi-Et)O%which corresponds with light planes of anaesthesia [minimum alveolar concentration (MAC <0.6)].
Thirty patients between 1 and 5 years of age undergoing short procedures were included. ETAG, MAC, BIS and (Fi-Et)O% were measured at intubation, maintenance phase, last 15 min of surgery, end of surgery, extubation, recovery. Pearson's correlation coefficient was used to measure correlation. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were used to derive cut-off value of (Fi-Et)O% which corresponded with MAC <0.6.
BIS correlated poorly with ETAG at all time intervals. Significant correlation was seen between (Fi-Et)O% and ETAG at intubation ( = 0.042), last 15 min of surgery ( = 0.019) and end of surgery ( = 0.001). Cut-off value >7 was obtained for (Fi-Et)O% corresponding to MAC <0.6 at extubation with area under ROC curve0.955 (95% confidence interval 0.811-0.997), with sensitivity 0.8571 and specificity 1.00.
BIS was an unreliable measure of anaesthetic depth. (Fi-Et)O% values >7 corresponded with light planes of anaesthesia.
呼气末麻醉气体浓度(ETAG)的测量目前是监测麻醉深度的一个实用指标。我们旨在评估七氟醚呼气末麻醉气体浓度(ETAG-七氟醚)联合脑电双频指数(BIS)以及吸入与呼气末氧浓度差值(Fi-Et)O%在测量幼儿及学龄前儿童麻醉深度方面的性能。主要结局是将BIS与ETAG-七氟醚进行相关性分析。次要结局是将(Fi-Et)O%与ETAG-七氟醚进行相关性分析,并得出与麻醉浅平面[最低肺泡浓度(MAC<0.6)]相对应的(Fi-Et)O%的截断值。
纳入30例年龄在1至5岁之间接受短小手术的患者。在插管、维持期、手术最后15分钟、手术结束、拔管、恢复时测量ETAG、MAC、BIS和(Fi-Et)O%。采用Pearson相关系数来测量相关性。采用受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线得出与MAC<0.6相对应的(Fi-Et)O%的截断值。
在所有时间间隔内,BIS与ETAG的相关性均较差。在插管时(=0.042)、手术最后15分钟(=0.019)和手术结束时(=0.001),(Fi-Et)O%与ETAG之间存在显著相关性。在拔管时,对应MAC<0.6的(Fi-Et)O%的截断值>7,ROC曲线下面积为0.955(95%置信区间0.811-0.997),敏感性为0.8571,特异性为1.00。
BIS是麻醉深度的不可靠测量指标。(Fi-Et)O%值>7与麻醉浅平面相对应。