School of Physical and Occupational Therapy, McGill University, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Centre for Interdisciplinary Research in Rehabilitation of Greater Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 2020 Jan;62(1):89-96. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.14252. Epub 2019 Apr 25.
To establish international expert recommendations on clinical features to prompt referral for diagnostic assessment of cerebral palsy (CP).
An online Delphi survey was conducted with international experts in early identification and intervention for children with CP, to validate the results obtained in two previous consensus groups with Canadian content experts and knowledge users. We sent two rounds of questionnaires by e-mail. Participants rated their agreement using a 4-point Likert scale, along with optional open-ended questions for additional feedback. Additionally, a panel of experts and knowledge-users reviewed the results of each round and determined the content of subsequent surveys.
Overall, there was high-level of agreement on: (1) six clinical features that should prompt referral for diagnosis; (2) two 'warning sign' features that warrant monitoring rather than immediate referral for diagnosis; and (3) five referral recommendations to other healthcare professionals to occur simultaneously with referral for diagnosis.
There was high agreement among international experts, suggesting that the features and referral recommendations proposed for primary care physicians for early detection of CP were broadly generalizable. These results will inform the content of educational tools to improve the early detection of CP in the primary care context.
International experts provide strong agreement on clinical features to detect cerebral palsy. Consensus on clinical 'warning signs' to monitor over time. Referral recommendations from primary care to specialized health services are identified.
制定有关临床特征的国际专家建议,以促使对脑瘫(CP)进行诊断评估。
对 CP 儿童早期识别和干预的国际专家进行在线 Delphi 调查,以验证之前与加拿大内容专家和知识使用者进行的两次共识小组中获得的结果。我们通过电子邮件发送了两轮问卷。参与者使用 4 分李克特量表对其达成一致的程度进行评分,并提供可选的开放式问题以提供其他反馈。此外,专家组和知识使用者审查了每轮的结果,并确定了后续调查的内容。
总体而言,对于以下方面达成了高度一致:(1)应提示进行诊断的六个临床特征;(2)两个需要监测而不是立即进行诊断的“警告特征”;(3)五项向其他医疗保健专业人员的转诊建议应与诊断转诊同时进行。
国际专家之间达成了高度一致,这表明为初级保健医生提出的用于早期发现 CP 的特征和转诊建议具有广泛的通用性。这些结果将为改进初级保健环境中 CP 的早期发现的教育工具的内容提供信息。
国际专家对可用于检测脑瘫的临床特征达成了强烈共识。对需要随时间进行监测的临床“警告信号”达成了共识。确定了从初级保健到专门健康服务的转诊建议。