Carragher Marcella, Ryan Brooke, Worrall Linda, Thomas Shirley, Rose Miranda, Simmons-Mackie Nina, Khan Asad, Hoffmann Tammy C, Power Emma, Togher Leanne, Kneebone Ian
School of Allied Health, Human Services and Sport, La Trobe University-Melbourne Campus, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, The University of Queensland, St Lucia, Queensland, Australia.
BMJ Open. 2019 May 5;9(5):e023560. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-023560.
Treatment fidelity is a complex, multifaceted evaluative process which refers to whether a studied intervention was delivered as intended. Monitoring and enhancing fidelity is one recommendation of the TiDIER (Template for Intervention Description and Replication) checklist, as fidelity can inform interpretation and conclusions drawn about treatment effects. Despite the methodological and translational benefits, fidelity strategies have been used inconsistently within health behaviour intervention studies; in particular, within aphasia intervention studies, reporting of fidelity remains relatively rare. This paper describes the development of a fidelity protocol for the Action Success Knowledge (ASK) study, a current cluster randomised trial investigating an early mood intervention for people with aphasia (a language disability caused by stroke).
A novel fidelity protocol and tool was developed to monitor and enhance fidelity within the two arms (experimental treatment and attention control) of the ASK study. The ASK fidelity protocol was developed based on the National Institutes of Health Behaviour Change Consortium fidelity framework.
The study protocol was approved by the Darling Downs Hospital and Health Service Human Research Ethics Committee in Queensland, Australia under the National Mutual Acceptance scheme of multicentre human research projects. Specific ethics approval was obtained for those participating sites who were not under the National Mutual Agreement at the time of application. The monitoring and ongoing conduct of the research project is in line with requirements under the National Mutual Acceptance. On completion of the trial, findings from the fidelity reviews will be disseminated via publications and conference presentations.
ACTRN12614000979651.
治疗保真度是一个复杂、多方面的评估过程,指所研究的干预措施是否按预期实施。监测和提高保真度是TiDIER(干预描述与复制模板)清单的一项建议,因为保真度可为关于治疗效果的解释和结论提供依据。尽管有方法学和转化方面的益处,但保真度策略在健康行为干预研究中使用并不一致;特别是在失语症干预研究中,保真度报告仍然相对较少。本文描述了行动成功知识(ASK)研究保真度方案的制定,ASK研究是一项正在进行的整群随机试验,旨在调查针对失语症(一种由中风导致的语言障碍)患者的早期情绪干预。
开发了一种新颖的保真度方案和工具,以监测和提高ASK研究两组(实验治疗组和注意力控制组)的保真度。ASK保真度方案是基于美国国立卫生研究院行为改变联盟保真度框架制定的。
该研究方案已获得澳大利亚昆士兰州达令唐斯医院与健康服务人类研究伦理委员会根据多中心人类研究项目的国家相互认可计划的批准。对于申请时不在国家相互协议范围内的参与站点,已获得特定的伦理批准。该研究项目的监测和持续开展符合国家相互认可的要求。试验完成后,保真度审查的结果将通过出版物和会议报告进行传播。
ACTRN12614000979651。