Cerebral Palsy Alliance Research Institute, Discipline of Child & Adolescent Health, Faculty of Medicine & Health, The University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
The Children's Hospital at Westmead, The Sydney Children's Hospitals Network, Sydney, Australia.
Dysphagia. 2020 Feb;35(1):1-17. doi: 10.1007/s00455-019-10016-x. Epub 2019 May 8.
Feeding difficulties and dysphagia are common in cerebral palsy (CP) and can lead to deficiencies of development and aspiration pneumonia; a leading cause of death in CP. Motor learning interventions have shown positive results in other clinical areas and may be beneficial for this population. This systematic review appraises research that addresses the question: are motor learning-based interventions more effective than compensatory strategies alone in treating dysphagia in infants with, or at risk of, CP?. Systematic searches were conducted in nine electronic databases. All levels of evidence, with at least one infant between 37 weeks post-menstrual age and 12 months corrected age who were at risk of, or diagnosed with CP, implemented interventions which aimed to improve oropharyngeal function for feeding, and aligned with at least two motor learning principles, were included. Studies were appraised by two independent reviewers using the Cho & Bero Instrument and GRADE. One historical case-control study and four case series met inclusion criteria. All involved a combination of motor learning interventions and compensatory strategies, which do not traditionally align with motor learning principles. All studies reported improvements in oral feeding outcomes, however, only three reported statistical analysis. The best available evidence collectively demonstrated a very weak positive effect for motor learning-based interventions for feeding difficulties in infants with, or at risk of, CP.
喂养困难和吞咽困难在脑瘫(CP)中很常见,可能导致发育不足和吸入性肺炎;这是 CP 的主要死亡原因。运动学习干预措施在其他临床领域已经显示出积极的结果,可能对这一人群有益。本系统评价评估了以下问题的研究:在治疗有或有 CP 风险的婴儿的吞咽困难方面,基于运动学习的干预措施是否比单纯的补偿策略更有效?系统检索了九个电子数据库。所有证据水平,至少有一名婴儿在 37 周妊娠龄和 12 个月矫正年龄之间,有 CP 风险或被诊断为 CP,实施了旨在改善喂养时口咽功能的干预措施,并且至少符合两个运动学习原则,都包括在内。研究由两名独立的审查员使用 Cho 和 Bero 仪器和 GRADE 进行评估。一项历史性病例对照研究和四项病例系列符合纳入标准。所有研究都涉及运动学习干预和补偿策略的结合,这些策略通常不符合运动学习原则。所有研究都报告了口腔喂养结果的改善,但只有三项研究报告了统计学分析。现有最佳证据总体上表明,基于运动学习的干预措施对有或有 CP 风险的婴儿的喂养困难有非常微弱的积极影响。