Blanco Fernández Gerardo, Gómez Bravo Miguel Ángel, Briceño Delgado Javier, Valdivieso López Andrés
Servicio de Cirugía Hepatobiliopancreática y Trasplante Hepático, Hospital Universitario de Badajoz, Universidad de Extremadura, Badajoz, España.
Sección de Cirugía Hepatobiliopancreática y Trasplante Hepático, Servicio de Cirugía General y del Aparato Digestivo, Hospital Universitario Virgen del Rocío, Sevilla, España; Sección de Cirugía HPB de la Asociación Española de Cirujanos.
Cir Esp (Engl Ed). 2019 Dec;97(10):560-567. doi: 10.1016/j.ciresp.2019.03.018. Epub 2019 May 9.
The access of surgeons to liver transplant teams in Spain is heterogeneous. This study aims to portray the current human resources of Spanish transplant teams, distribution of transplant duties among team members, how transplant team members acquire their skills, their leaders' view of their future, as well the motivations of Spanish General Surgery residents to choose transplantation as their future career choice.
Two different surveys were created, one for head surgeons and one for residents, about the number of team members and their training, recruitment, organization of tasks and motivation to work in transplantation. The questionnaires were e-mailed to both the transplant program directors and the surgical residents.
There are on average 8 surgeons in each transplant unit. More than four surgeons perform the hepatectomy in 54.2% of the groups, while the graft implantation is performed by more than 4 surgeons at just 25% of the centers. Forty-two percent of the transplant chiefs advocated a fellowship training system, and 87.5% believe that generational turnover is guaranteed. Out of 525 residents, 101 responded. Regarding training, 12.8% had no interest in transplantation. Concerning their work preferences, 37.6% were not interested in transplantation because it is excessively demanding, and 52.5% would not like to be part of a liver transplant team in the future.
The generational turnover seems to be guaranteed according to liver transplant program directors. The new generations of surgeons generally opt for other areas of surgery other than transplantation. Studies with a greater number of responses are necessary to validate these results.
在西班牙,外科医生加入肝移植团队的机会并不均等。本研究旨在描述西班牙移植团队目前的人力资源状况、团队成员之间移植职责的分配情况、移植团队成员如何获得技能、他们的领导者对未来的看法,以及西班牙普通外科住院医师选择移植作为未来职业的动机。
针对主刀医生和住院医师分别设计了两份不同的调查问卷,内容涉及团队成员数量及其培训、招募、任务组织以及从事移植工作的动机。问卷通过电子邮件发送给移植项目主任和外科住院医师。
每个移植单位平均有8名外科医生。在54.2%的团队中,超过4名外科医生进行肝切除术,而在仅25%的中心,超过4名外科医生进行移植物植入。42%的移植负责人主张采用专科培训体系,87.5%的人认为代际更替有保障。在525名住院医师中,101人回复。关于培训,12.8%的人对移植不感兴趣。关于他们的工作偏好,37.6%的人对移植不感兴趣,因为其要求过高,52.5%的人未来不想成为肝移植团队的一员。
根据肝移植项目主任的说法,代际更替似乎有保障。新一代外科医生通常选择移植以外的其他外科领域。需要更多回复的研究来验证这些结果。