Li Yao-Lei, Jin Hong-Yu, Xiang Xin-Hua, Ma Shuang-Cheng
National Institutes for Food and Drug Control Beijing 100050,China.
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi. 2019 Apr;44(8):1724-1728. doi: 10.19540/j.cnki.cjcmm.20190118.003.
This study aims to explore the evaluation model for the proficiency testing of heavy metal and harmful element residues in pharmaceuticals,and to provide reference for the proficiency testing program and proficiency testing result in the field of residue analysis. The proficiency test result of cadmium determination in honeysuckle as an example. The algorithm A,NIQR,and Horwitz function are used to calculate the assigned value and the standard deviation. Z was obtained at the same time. If | Z | ≤2,the result is satisfactory. If 2< | Z | <3,the result is questionable. If | Z | ≥3,the result is unsatisfactory. In addition,the median value is the assigned value,and deviation(D%) is used. If D% is not more than 16%,the result is satisfactory; if D% is more than 16%,the result is unsatisfactory. After analysis,in the results of questionable or dissatisfied laboratories calculated by algorithm A and NIQR,the deviation error of some data is within the scope of the standard. In the results of the satisfactory laboratory evaluated by the Horwitz function,some data deviation errors far exceed the standard range. The evaluation result of the D% meets the requirements. According to heavy metal and harmful element trace analysis methods,this study is the first to apply D% to the evaluation of the detection ability of heavy metals and harmful elements in pharmaceuticals. This method makes the evaluation result more reasonable,and has important reference significance for the evaluation of other proficiency test results.
本研究旨在探索药品中重金属及有害元素残留量能力验证的评估模型,为残留量分析领域的能力验证方案及能力验证结果提供参考。以金银花中镉测定能力验证结果为例,采用算法A、NIQR及Horwitz函数计算赋值和标准差,同时得出Z值,若|Z|≤2,结果为满意;若2<|Z|<3,结果为可疑;若|Z|≥3,结果为不满意。此外,以中位值为赋值,采用偏差(D%)进行判断,若D%不超过16%,结果为满意;若D%超过16%,结果为不满意。经分析,在算法A和NIQR计算的可疑或不满意实验室结果中,部分数据偏差误差在标准范围内;在Horwitz函数评价为满意的实验室结果中,部分数据偏差误差远超标准范围,D%评价结果符合要求。本研究首次将D%应用于药品重金属及有害元素检测能力评价,依据重金属及有害元素痕量分析方法,该方法使评价结果更合理,对其他能力验证结果评价具有重要参考意义。