Volchenko Elan, Schwarzman Garrett, Robinson Matthew, Chmell Samuel J, Gonzalez Mark H
Orthopedics. 2019 May 1;42(3):163-167. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20190424-08.
Arthrofibrosis following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is a debilitating complication. Treatment options include physical therapy, manipulation under anesthesia (MUA), and arthroscopic lysis of adhesions (ALOA) with or without MUA. The authors studied 70 patients with arthrofibrosis after TKA treated with MUA or ALOA plus MUA. In this matched cohort study, 35 patients were treated with MUA and 35 patients were treated with ALOA plus MUA. Total knee arthroplasty followed by MUA was performed by 2 surgeons and TKA followed by MUA plus ALOA was performed by 1 surgeon at 1 institution. Electronic records were used to collect information and match cohorts based on age, sex, body mass index, diabetes mellitus, perioperative range of motion (ROM), and timing of the procedure for arthrofibrosis. The combination of MUA and ALOA yielded changes in ROM: a 72.7% increase 4 to 12 weeks after index TKA (P=.032), a 50.0% increase 12+ weeks after TKA (P=.032), and a 99.8% increase in patients with a pre-manipulation ROM of 0° to 60° (P=.001). Manipulation under anesthesia yielded a 49.2% increase 4 to 12 weeks after TKA (P=.161), a 27.0% increase 12+ weeks after TKA (P=.161), and a 68.8% increase in patients with pre-manipulation ROM of 0° to 60° (P=.084). Patients treated with ALOA plus MUA had greater increases in ROM (P=.026) and final knee flexion (P=.028) compared with those treated with MUA alone. Arthrofibrosis following TKA is a complication that often requires additional procedures. Traditionally, ALOA is added 3+ months from index TKA, when abundant scar formation has occurred. This study found a benefit to ALOA plus MUA compared with MUA alone, with the largest benefit in patients whose pre-manipulation ROM was 0° to 60°. [Orthopedics. 2019; 42(3):163-167.].
全膝关节置换术(TKA)后关节纤维化是一种使人衰弱的并发症。治疗选择包括物理治疗、麻醉下手法松解(MUA)以及伴或不伴MUA的关节镜下粘连松解术(ALOA)。作者研究了70例TKA后发生关节纤维化并接受MUA或ALOA加MUA治疗的患者。在这项配对队列研究中,35例患者接受MUA治疗,35例患者接受ALOA加MUA治疗。在1家机构,2名外科医生进行了TKA后MUA,1名外科医生进行了TKA后MUA加ALOA。利用电子记录收集信息,并根据年龄、性别、体重指数、糖尿病、围手术期活动范围(ROM)以及关节纤维化手术的时间对队列进行匹配。MUA和ALOA联合使用使ROM发生了变化:在初次TKA后4至12周增加了72.7%(P = 0.032),在TKA后12周以上增加了50.0%(P = 0.032),在手法松解前ROM为0°至60°的患者中增加了99.8%(P = 0.001)。麻醉下手法松解在TKA后4至12周增加了49.2%(P = 0.161),在TKA后12周以上增加了27.0%(P = 0.161),在手法松解前ROM为0°至60°的患者中增加了68.8%(P = 0.084)。与单独接受MUA治疗的患者相比,接受ALOA加MUA治疗的患者ROM增加幅度更大(P = 0.026),最终膝关节屈曲度增加幅度更大(P = 0.028)。TKA后关节纤维化是一种通常需要额外手术的并发症。传统上,在初次TKA后3个月以上,即出现大量瘢痕形成时加做ALOA。这项研究发现,与单独使用MUA相比,ALOA加MUA有好处,在手法松解前ROM为0°至60°的患者中获益最大。[《骨科》。2019年;42(3):163 - 167。]