The Public Health Agency of Sweden, Department of Communicable Disease Control and Health Protection, Folkhälsomyndigheten, SE-171 82, Solna, Sweden.
World Health Organization, Department of Immunization, Vaccines and Biologicals, 1202 Geneva, Switzerland.
Public Health. 2019 Jun;171:97-105. doi: 10.1016/j.puhe.2019.04.008. Epub 2019 May 20.
National vaccination coverage in Sweden is high. Recurrent outbreaks of measles and rubella however highlight some immunity gaps in the population. Current knowledge about immunization status of undocumented migrant children is scant. The World Health Organization/Europe has developed the Guide to Tailoring Immunization Programmes (TIP) to assist countries in diagnosing barriers and motivators to vaccination in communities with low vaccination coverage. Based on the TIP guide, the objective of this study was to explore determinants to vaccination among undocumented immigrants, using qualitative approach.
The study consisted of three steps: (i) an initial workshop for problem statement; (ii) qualitative research for increased understanding of the vaccination practices of children in the undocumented community; and (iii) a second workshop to incorporate the qualitative interview findings together with data from key stakeholders into a conceptual framework.
This was a qualitative study featuring interviews of seven undocumented parents recruited at non-governmental clinics, three nurses at Child Health Centers, and information from key stakeholders retrieved at workshops as part of the TIP process.
The content analysis revealed two main themes: parental fear of being questioned and parental acceptance of child immunization. Undocumented parents had a positive view and attitude toward childhood immunization but expressed strong fear of being asked for identification papers at healthcare facilities. Owing to lack of knowledge on entitlements of the undocumented among health personnel, parents were incorrectly rejected when seeking care for their children. Frequent mobility among undocumented may limit access to complete the immunization schedule. Undocumented parents mistrust healthcare providers and avoid health facilities, further delaying childrens' access to health care, including immunization services.
The findings of this study confirm the complexity of barriers that undocumented parents face regarding childhood immunization. The TIP guide offers a valuable process for a deeper understanding of the determinants of immunization challenges among undocumented migrants.
瑞典的全国疫苗接种覆盖率很高。然而,麻疹和风疹的反复爆发凸显了人群中存在一些免疫空白。目前,关于无证移民儿童免疫状况的知识很少。世界卫生组织/欧洲制定了《免疫规划调整指南》(TIP),以帮助各国诊断免疫覆盖率低的社区中疫苗接种的障碍和促进因素。本研究基于 TIP 指南,采用定性方法探讨无证移民接种疫苗的决定因素。
该研究包括三个步骤:(i)初始研讨会,陈述问题;(ii)定性研究,以深入了解无证社区儿童的疫苗接种情况;(iii)第二次研讨会,将定性访谈结果与关键利益相关者的数据纳入概念框架。
这是一项定性研究,对在非政府诊所招募的 7 名无证父母、3 名儿童健康中心护士进行了访谈,并从 TIP 过程中的研讨会中获取了关键利益相关者的信息。
内容分析揭示了两个主要主题:父母担心被盘问和父母对儿童免疫的接受。无证父母对儿童免疫接种有积极的看法和态度,但表示强烈担心在医疗保健机构被要求出示身份证件。由于卫生人员对无证人员的权利缺乏了解,父母在为子女寻求医疗保健时被错误拒绝。无证人员经常流动可能会限制他们获得完整免疫接种计划的机会。无证父母不信任医疗服务提供者,避免前往医疗保健机构,进一步延迟儿童获得包括免疫服务在内的医疗保健。
本研究结果证实了无证父母在儿童免疫接种方面面临的障碍的复杂性。TIP 指南为深入了解无证移民免疫挑战的决定因素提供了一个有价值的过程。