Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of Ghana, Accra, Ghana.
Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, University Medical Center, Utrecht University, Utrecht, Netherlands.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2019 May 24;7(5):e12879. doi: 10.2196/12879.
Developing and maintaining resilient health systems in low-resource settings like Ghana requires innovative approaches that adapt technology to context to improve health outcomes. One such innovation was a mobile health (mHealth) clinical decision-making support system (mCDMSS) that utilized text messaging (short message service, SMS) of standard emergency maternal and neonatal protocols via an unstructured supplementary service data (USSD) on request of the health care providers. This mCDMSS was implemented in a cluster randomized controlled trial (CRCT) in the Eastern Region of Ghana.
This study aimed to analyze the pattern of requests made to the USSD by health workers (HWs). We assessed the relationship between requests made to the USSD and types of maternal and neonatal morbidities reported in health facilities (HFs).
For clusters in the intervention arm of the CRCT, all requests to the USSD during the 18-month intervention period were extracted from a remote server, and maternal and neonatal health outcomes of interest were obtained from the District Health Information System of Ghana. Chi-square and Fisher exact tests were used to compare the proportion and type of requests made to the USSD by cluster, facility type, and location; whether phones accessing the intervention were shared facility phones or individual-use phones (type-of-phone); or whether protocols were accessed during the day or at night (time-of-day). Trends in requests made were analyzed over 3 6-month periods. The relationship between requests made and the number of cases reported in HFs was assessed using Spearman correlation.
In total, 5329 requests from 72 (97%) participating HFs were made to the intervention. The average number of requests made per cluster was 667. Requests declined from the first to the third 6-month period (44.96% [2396/5329], 39.82% [2122/5329], and 15.22% [811/5329], respectively). Maternal conditions accounted for the majority of requests made (66.35% [3536/5329]). The most frequently accessed maternal conditions were postpartum hemorrhage (25.23% [892/3536]), other conditions (17.82% [630/3536]), and hypertension (16.49% [583/3536]), whereas the most frequently accessed neonatal conditions were prematurity (20.08% [360/1793]), sepsis (15.45% [277/1793]), and resuscitation (13.78% [247/1793]). Requests made to the mCDMSS varied significantly by cluster, type of request (maternal or neonatal), facility type and its location, type-of-phone, and time-of-day at 6-month interval (P<.001 for each variable). Trends in maternal and neonatal requests showed varying significance over each 6-month interval. Only asphyxia and sepsis cases showed significant correlations with the number of requests made (r=0.44 and r=0.79; P<.001 and P=.03, respectively).
There were variations in the pattern of requests made to the mCDMSS over time. Detailed information regarding the use of the mCDMSS provides insight into the information needs of HWs for decision-making and an opportunity to focus support for HW training and ultimately improved maternal and neonatal health.
在加纳等资源匮乏的环境中,开发和维护有弹性的卫生系统需要创新的方法,使技术适应环境,以改善健康结果。一种这样的创新是移动医疗(mHealth)临床决策支持系统(mCDMSS),它通过在卫生保健提供者的请求下使用标准紧急产妇和新生儿协议的文本消息(短消息服务,SMS)来利用非结构化补充服务数据(USSD)。该 mCDMSS 在加纳东部地区的一项集群随机对照试验(CRCT)中得到实施。
本研究旨在分析卫生工作者(HWs)向 USSD 提出的请求模式。我们评估了向 USSD 提出的请求与在卫生机构(HFs)报告的产妇和新生儿发病率之间的关系。
对于 CRCT 干预臂中的集群,在 18 个月的干预期间,所有对 USSD 的请求都从远程服务器中提取出来,并且从加纳地区卫生信息系统中获得了感兴趣的产妇和新生儿健康结果。使用卡方检验和 Fisher 精确检验比较了按集群、设施类型和位置提出的 USSD 请求的比例和类型;访问干预措施的手机是共享设施手机还是个人使用手机(手机类型);或者协议是在白天还是晚上访问(访问时间)。分析了在三个 6 个月期间提出的请求趋势。使用 Spearman 相关分析评估了提出的请求与 HFs 报告的病例数量之间的关系。
共有来自 72 个(97%)参与 HFs 的 5329 个请求发送至干预措施。每个集群的平均请求数量为 667 个。从第一个到第三个 6 个月期间,请求数量下降(44.96%[2396/5329]、39.82%[2122/5329]和 15.22%[811/5329])。产妇情况占提出请求的大部分(66.35%[3536/5329])。最常访问的产妇情况是产后出血(25.23%[892/3536])、其他情况(17.82%[630/3536])和高血压(16.49%[583/3536]),而最常访问的新生儿情况是早产(20.08%[360/1793])、败血症(15.45%[277/1793])和复苏(13.78%[247/1793])。向 mCDMSS 提出的请求在每个 6 个月间隔时间内,按集群、请求类型(产妇或新生儿)、设施类型及其位置、手机类型和访问时间,存在显著差异(P<.001,每个变量)。产妇和新生儿请求的趋势在每个 6 个月间隔时间内显示出不同的显著程度。只有窒息和败血症病例与提出的请求数量呈显著相关(r=0.44 和 r=0.79;P<.001 和 P=.03)。
向 mCDMSS 提出的请求模式随时间而变化。有关 mCDMSS 使用情况的详细信息提供了对 HWs 决策所需信息的了解,并为 HW 培训提供了支持机会,最终改善了产妇和新生儿的健康。