Vedel Isabelle, Sourial Nadia, Arsenault-Lapierre Genevieve, Godard-Sebillotte Claire, Bergman Howard
Department of Family Medicine (Vedel, Sourial, Godard-Sebillotte, Bergman), McGill University; Lady Davis Institute (Vedel, Sourial, Arsenault-Lapierre), Jewish General Hospital, Montréal, Que.
CMAJ Open. 2019 Jun 14;7(2):E391-E398. doi: 10.9778/cmajo.20190053. Print 2019 Apr-Jun.
The Quebec Alzheimer Plan aims to improve care provided to patients with neurocognitive disorders in Family Medicine Groups (FMGs) (multidisciplinary team-based primary care practices). The objective of this study was to determine changes in the detection and management of neurocognitive disorders following implementation of the plan, in 2014.
This was a retrospective chart review before and after implementation of the Quebec Alzheimer Plan in 13 FMGs. We reviewed 1919 randomly selected charts of patients aged 75 years or more and 945 randomly selected charts of patients in this age group with neurocognitive disorders. In the first group, selected outcomes were proportion of patients with documentation of cognitive status, documented diagnosis of neurocognitive disorder, documented cognitive testing and referral to a memory clinic. In patients with neurocognitive disorders, the outcomes were number of contacts with an FMG, quality of follow-up score (documented assessments in 10 domains: cognitive testing, functional status, behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia, weight, caregiver needs, driving status, home care needs, community service needs, absence of anticholinergic medication and management of dementia medications) and proportion referred to a memory clinic.
Significantly more patients aged 75 or more had documentation of cognitive status in their chart after plan implementation than before implementation (440 [45.1%] v. 351 [37.2%]) (odds ratio [OR] 1.46, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.18-1.81). No significant changes were found in documented diagnosis of neurocognitive disorders, cognitive testing or referral to a memory clinic. Among patients with neurocognitive disorders, the number of contacts with an FMG (adjusted mean difference 1.6, 95% CI 0.3-2.8) and quality of follow-up score (adjusted mean difference 6.6, 95% CI 3.9-9.2) increased significantly, without significant changes in the number of referrals to a memory clinic.
The results suggest that the Quebec Alzheimer Plan is feasible and beneficial in terms of detection and management of neurocognitive disorders, without an increase in referral to specialists. The findings will be used to scale up the Quebec Alzheimer Plan and to develop the Canadian federal dementia strategy.
魁北克老年痴呆症计划旨在改善家庭医疗小组(FMGs,基于多学科团队的初级医疗实践)为神经认知障碍患者提供的护理。本研究的目的是确定2014年该计划实施后神经认知障碍的检测和管理方面的变化。
这是一项对13个家庭医疗小组实施魁北克老年痴呆症计划前后的病历进行回顾性研究。我们查阅了1919份随机抽取的75岁及以上患者的病历,以及945份随机抽取的该年龄组神经认知障碍患者的病历。在第一组中,选定的结果包括记录有认知状态的患者比例、记录有神经认知障碍诊断的患者比例、记录有认知测试的患者比例以及转介至记忆诊所的患者比例。在患有神经认知障碍的患者中,结果包括与家庭医疗小组的接触次数、随访质量评分(在10个领域有记录的评估:认知测试、功能状态、痴呆的行为和心理症状、体重、照顾者需求、驾驶状态、家庭护理需求、社区服务需求、无抗胆碱能药物以及痴呆药物管理)以及转介至记忆诊所的患者比例。
计划实施后,75岁及以上患者病历中记录有认知状态的比例显著高于实施前(440例[45.1%]对351例[37.2%])(优势比[OR]为1.46,95%置信区间[CI]为1.18 - 1.81)。在记录的神经认知障碍诊断、认知测试或转介至记忆诊所方面未发现显著变化。在患有神经认知障碍的患者中,与家庭医疗小组的接触次数(调整后平均差异为1.6,95% CI为0.3 - 2.8)和随访质量评分(调整后平均差异为6.6,95% CI为3.9 - 9.2)显著增加,而转介至记忆诊所的次数没有显著变化。
结果表明,魁北克老年痴呆症计划在神经认知障碍的检测和管理方面是可行且有益的,且不会增加转介至专科医生的人数。这些发现将用于扩大魁北克老年痴呆症计划,并制定加拿大联邦痴呆症战略。