Knipe Duleeka, Metcalfe Chris, Hawton Keith, Pearson Melissa, Dawson Andrew, Jayamanne Shaluka, Konradsen Flemming, Eddleston Michael, Gunnell David
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK; South Asian Clinical Toxicology Research Collaboration (SACTRC), Faculty of Medicine, University of Peradeniya, Peradeniya, Sri Lanka.
Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
Lancet Psychiatry. 2019 Aug;6(8):659-666. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(19)30214-7. Epub 2019 Jul 1.
Evidence from high income countries (HICs) suggests that individuals who present to hospital after self-harm are an important target for suicide prevention, but evidence from low and middle-income countries (LMICs) is lacking. We aimed to investigate the risk of repeat self-harm and suicide, and factors associated with these outcomes, in a large cohort of patients presenting to hospital with self-harm in rural Sri Lanka.
In this cohort study, hospital presentations for self-harm at 13 hospitals in a rural area of North Central Province (population 224 000), Sri Lanka, were followed up with a self-harm surveillance system, established as part of a community randomised trial, and based on data from all hospitals, coroners, and police stations in the study area. We estimated the risk of repeat non-fatal and fatal self-harm and risk factors for repetition with Kaplan-Meier methods and Cox proportional hazard models. Sociodemographic (age, sex, and socioeconomic position) and clinical (past self-harm and method of self-harm) characteristics investigated were drawn from a household survey in the study area and data recorded at the time of index hospital presentation. We included all individuals who had complete data for all variables in the study in our primary analysis.
Between July 29, 2011, and May 12, 2016, we detected 3073 episodes of self-harm (fatal and non-fatal) in our surveillance system, of which 2532 (82·3%) were linked back to an individual in the baseline survey. After exclusion of 145 ineligible episodes, we analysed 2259 index episodes of self-harm. By use of survival models, the estimated risk of repeat self-harm (12 months: 3· 1%, 95% CI 2·4-3·9; 24 months: 5·2%, 4·3-6·4) and suicide (12 months: 0·6%, 0·4-1·1; 24 months: 0·8%, 0·5-1·3) in our study was considerably lower than that in HICs. A higher risk of repeat self-harm was observed in men than in women (fatal and non-fatal; hazard ratio 2·0, 95% CI 1·3-3·2; p=0·0021), in individuals aged 56 years and older compared with those aged 10-25 years (fatal; 16·1, 4·3-59·9; p=0·0027), and those who used methods other than poisoning in their index presentation (fatal and non-fatal; 3·9, 2·0-7·6; p=0·00027). We found no evidence of increased risk of repeat self-harm or suicide in those with a history of self-harm before the index episode.
Although people who self-harm are an important high-risk group, focusing suicide prevention efforts on those who self-harm might be somewhat less important in LMICs compared with HICs given the low risk of repeat self-harm and subsequent suicide death. Strategies that focus on other risk factors for suicide might be more effective in reducing suicide deaths in LMICs in south Asia. A better understanding of the low incidence of repeat self-harm is also needed, as this could contribute to prevention strategies in nations with a higher incidence of repetition and subsequent suicide death.
Wellcome Trust.
高收入国家(HICs)的证据表明,因自残而住院的个体是预防自杀的重要目标人群,但低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)缺乏相关证据。我们旨在调查在斯里兰卡农村地区因自残而住院的一大群患者中重复自残和自杀的风险,以及与这些结果相关的因素。
在这项队列研究中,利用作为社区随机试验一部分建立的自残监测系统,对斯里兰卡中北省农村地区(人口22.4万)13家医院的自残住院情况进行随访,该监测系统基于研究区域内所有医院、验尸官和警察局的数据。我们采用Kaplan-Meier方法和Cox比例风险模型估计重复非致命和致命自残的风险以及重复自残的风险因素。所调查的社会人口学特征(年龄、性别和社会经济地位)和临床特征(既往自残史和自残方式)来自研究区域的家庭调查以及首次住院时记录的数据。我们在主要分析中纳入了所有在研究中拥有所有变量完整数据的个体。
在2011年7月29日至2016年5月12日期间,我们在监测系统中检测到3073例自残事件(致命和非致命),其中2532例(82.3%)可追溯到基线调查中的个体。排除145例不符合条件的事件后,我们分析了2259例首次自残事件。通过生存模型估计,我们研究中重复自残的风险(12个月:3.1%,95%CI 2.4 - 3.9;24个月:5.2%,4.3 - 6.4)和自杀风险(12个月:0.6%,0.4 - 1.1;24个月:0.8%,0.5 - 1.3)远低于高收入国家。男性重复自残的风险高于女性(致命和非致命;风险比2.0,95%CI 1.3 - 3.2;p = 0.0021),56岁及以上个体与10 - 25岁个体相比重复自残风险更高(致命;16.1,4.3 - 59.9;p = 0.0027),以及在首次就诊时使用除中毒以外方式的个体(致命和非致命;3.9,2.0 - 7.6;p = 0.00027)。我们没有发现首次事件前有自残史的个体重复自残或自杀风险增加的证据。
尽管自残者是重要的高风险群体,但鉴于重复自残和随后自杀死亡的风险较低,与高收入国家相比,在低收入和中等收入国家将自杀预防工作重点放在自残者身上可能不太重要。关注其他自杀风险因素的策略可能在降低南亚低收入和中等收入国家的自杀死亡方面更有效。还需要更好地理解重复自残发生率低的原因,因为这可能有助于在重复自残及随后自杀死亡发生率较高的国家制定预防策略。
惠康信托基金会。