Department of Psychology, Durham University, Durham DH1 3LE, UK.
Department of Psychological Sciences, Birkbeck, University of London, London WC1E 7HX, UK.
Cognition. 2019 Dec;193:104014. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2019.104014. Epub 2019 Jul 11.
Cue combination occurs when two independent noisy perceptual estimates are merged together as a weighted average, creating a unified estimate that is more precise than either single estimate alone. Surprisingly, this effect has not been demonstrated compellingly in children under the age of 10 years, in contrast with the array of other multisensory skills that children show even in infancy. Instead, across a wide variety of studies, precision with both cues is no better than the best single cue - and sometimes worse. Here we provide the first consistent evidence of cue combination in children from 7 to 10 years old. Across three experiments, participants showed evidence of a bimodal precision advantage (Experiments 1a and 1b) and the majority were best-fit by a combining model (Experiment 2). The task was to localize a target horizontally with a binaural audio cue and a noisy visual cue in immersive virtual reality. Feedback was given as well, which could both (a) help participants judge how reliable each cue is and (b) help correct between-cue biases that might prevent cue combination. Crucially, our results show cue combination when feedback is only given on single cues - therefore, combination itself was not a strategy learned via feedback. We suggest that children at 7-10 years old are capable of cue combination in principle, but must have sufficient representations of reliabilities and biases in their own perceptual estimates as relevant to the task, which can be facilitated through task-specific feedback.
线索组合发生在两个独立的噪声知觉估计被合并在一起作为加权平均,创建一个更精确的统一估计,比任何单一的估计。令人惊讶的是,这种效应在 10 岁以下的儿童中并没有得到有力的证明,而在其他多种多感官技能中,儿童甚至在婴儿期就表现出了这些技能。相反,在各种各样的研究中,两种线索的精度都不如最好的单一线索——有时甚至更差。在这里,我们提供了第一个一致的证据,表明 7 到 10 岁的儿童有线索组合。在三个实验中,参与者表现出双峰精度优势的证据(实验 1a 和 1b),大多数人最适合组合模型(实验 2)。任务是在沉浸式虚拟现实中用双耳音频线索和嘈杂的视觉线索定位一个目标。也会提供反馈,这既可以帮助参与者判断每个线索的可靠性,也可以帮助纠正可能阻止线索组合的线索之间的偏差。至关重要的是,我们的结果表明,当反馈只给单个线索时,会出现线索组合——因此,组合本身不是通过反馈学习的策略。我们认为,7 至 10 岁的儿童原则上能够进行线索组合,但必须对自己的感知估计有足够的可靠性和偏差的表示,这可以通过特定于任务的反馈来促进。