Frommer D J, Kapparis A, Brown M K
Department of Medicine, St Vincent's Hospital, Darlinghurst, New South Wales, Australia.
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1988 Apr 16;296(6629):1092-4. doi: 10.1136/bmj.296.6629.1092.
A radial immunodiffusion technique for detecting faecal haemoglobin and the Hemoccult II kit used with and without rehydration of the faecal sample were compared in a screening programme for bowel cancer, in which 1328 subjects took part. A positive result was obtained in 170 (13%) subjects. Nineteen of the 153 subjects investigated were found to have colorectal carcinomas and 52 had polyps (40 with adenomas). Radial immunodiffusion and Hemoccult II with and without rehydration detected bleeding in, respectively, all 19, 15, and 11 subjects with colorectal carcinoma. Hemoccult II with and without rehydration detected only seven and six, respectively, of 11 Duke's stage A carcinomas, whereas all 11 were detected with the immunological test. Hemoccult II with and without rehydration and radial immunodiffusion detected bleeding from adenomas in, respectively, 22, 14, and 34 of the 40 subjects. False positive results occurred in 55 out of 1302 subjects by Hemoccult II with rehydration, in 28 out of 1304 by Hemoccult II without rehydration, and in 50 out of 1304 by the immunological technique; true positive results were defined as bleeding from carcinomas and adenomas. Immunological detection of occult blood in faecal samples seems to show more adenomas and carcinomas (particularly early lesions) than the Hemoccult II kit and has a rate of false positive results that is acceptably low.
在一项有1328名受试者参与的肠癌筛查项目中,对用于检测粪便血红蛋白的放射免疫扩散技术以及在粪便样本复水和不复水情况下使用的Hemoccult II试剂盒进行了比较。170名(13%)受试者检测结果呈阳性。在153名接受调查的受试者中,19人被发现患有结直肠癌,52人有息肉(40人有腺瘤)。放射免疫扩散法以及复水和不复水情况下的Hemoccult II分别在所有19名、15名和11名结直肠癌患者中检测到出血。复水和不复水情况下的Hemoccult II分别仅在11例杜克A期癌中的7例和6例中检测到出血,而免疫检测法检测到了所有11例。复水和不复水情况下的Hemoccult II以及放射免疫扩散法分别在40例有腺瘤的受试者中的22例、14例和34例中检测到腺瘤出血。复水情况下的Hemoccult II在1302名受试者中有55例假阳性结果,不复水情况下的Hemoccult II在1304名受试者中有28例假阳性结果,免疫技术在1304名受试者中有50例假阳性结果;真阳性结果定义为癌和腺瘤出血。粪便样本中潜血的免疫检测似乎比Hemoccult II试剂盒能检测出更多的腺瘤和癌(尤其是早期病变),且假阳性结果率低到可以接受。