Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Töölö Hospital, Helsinki University Hospital.
Department of Pediatric Orthopedics and Traumatology, Helsinki New Children's Hospital; Finland.
Acta Orthop. 2019 Dec;90(6):610-613. doi: 10.1080/17453674.2019.1643632. Epub 2019 Jul 22.
Background and purpose - Unnecessary radiographic and clinical follow-ups are common in treatment of pediatric fractures. We hypothesized that follow-up radiographs are unnecessary to monitor union of physeal fractures of the distal tibia.Patients and methods - All 224 (147 boys) children under 16 years old treated for a physeal fracture of the distal tibia during a 5-year period (2010-14) in Helsinki Children's Hospital were included in this study. Peterson type II fractures comprised 55% and transitional fractures (Tillaux and Triplane) 20% of all injuries. Fracture displacement and alignment was measured. Type and place of treatment was recorded. Number of follow-up radiographs and outpatient visits was calculated and their clinical significance was assessed.Results - 109 children had fractures with < 2 mm displacement and no angulation. The other 115 children's mean fracture displacement was 6 mm (2-28). 54% of all children were treated by casting in situ in the emergency room, 20% with manipulation under anesthesia and 26% with surgery (internal 57, external fixation 2). Median 3 (1-7) follow-up appointments and median 3 (0-6) radiographs were taken. Follow-up radiographs at or before cast removal did not alter treatment in any of the patients. 223 patients' fractures healed within 4-9 weeks in good alignment (≤ 5° angulation).Interpretation - Routine radiographic follow-up is unnecessary to monitor alignment and union of physeal fractures of the distal tibia.
背景与目的 - 在儿童骨折的治疗中,进行不必要的影像学和临床随访较为常见。我们假设,对于胫骨远端骺板骨折,随访 X 光片对于监测愈合是不必要的。
患者与方法 - 本研究纳入了在赫尔辛基儿童医院接受胫骨远端骺板骨折治疗的 224 名(147 名男性)16 岁以下儿童,随访时间为 5 年(2010-14 年)。所有患者中,55%为 Peterson Ⅱ型骨折,20%为过渡型骨折(Tillaux 和 Triplane)。测量骨折移位和对线情况。记录治疗方式和部位。计算随访 X 光片和门诊就诊的次数,并评估其临床意义。
结果 - 109 名儿童的骨折存在<2mm 的移位且无成角。其余 115 名儿童的平均骨折移位为 6mm(2-28mm)。54%的儿童在急诊室接受原位石膏固定,20%接受麻醉下手法复位,26%接受手术治疗(内固定 57 例,外固定 2 例)。中位数随访 3(1-7)次,中位数拍摄 X 光片 3(0-6)次。在去除石膏之前的任何一次随访 X 光片都没有改变治疗方式。223 名患者的骨折在 4-9 周内愈合,对线良好(≤5°成角)。
结论 - 对于胫骨远端骺板骨折,常规影像学随访对于监测对线和愈合是不必要的。