Cronshaw Mark, Parker Steven, Arany Praveen
Department of Surgical Sciences and Integrated Diagnostics, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy.
Department of Oral Biology and Biomedical Engineering, School of Dental Medicine, Engineering and Applied Sciences, University at Buffalo, Buffalo, New York.
Photobiomodul Photomed Laser Surg. 2019 Sep;37(9):517-526. doi: 10.1089/photob.2019.4684. Epub 2019 Jul 19.
The clinical therapeutic benefits of Photobiomodulation (PBM) therapy have been well established in many clinical scenarios. However, we are far from having developed a complete understanding of the underlying mechanisms of photon-biological tissue interactions. Concurrent to ongoing PBM studies, there are several parallel fields with evidences from cell and tissue physiology such as evolutionary biology, photobiology, and microbiology among others. This review is focused on extrapolating evidences from an expanded range of studies that may contribute to a better understanding of PBM mechanisms especially focusing on analgesia. Further, the choice of a PBM device source and relevant dosimetry with regards to specific mechanisms are discussed to enable broader clinical use of PBM therapies. This discussion article is referenced from an expanded range of peer reviewed publications, including literature associated with evolutionary biology, microbiology, oncology, and photo-optical imaging technology, amongst others. Materials drawn from many disparate disciplines is described. By inference from the current evidence base, a novel theory is offered to partially explain the cellular basis of PBM-induced analgesia. It is proposed that this may involve the activity of a class of transmembrane proteins known as uncoupling proteins. Furthermore, it is proposed that this may activate the heat stress protein response and that intracellur microthermal inclines may be of significance in PBM analgesia. It is suggested that the PBM dose response as a simple binary model of PBM effects as represented by the Arndt-Schulz law is clinically less useful than a multiphasic biological response. Finally, comments are made concerning the nature of photon to tissue interaction that can have significance in regard to the effective choice and delivery of dose to clinical target. It is suggested that a re-evaluation of phototransduction pathways may lead to an improvement in outcome in phototheraphy. An enhanced knowledge of safe parameters and a better knowledge of the mechanics of action at target level will permit more reliable and predictable clinical gain and assist the acceptance of PBM therapy within the wider medical community.
光生物调节(PBM)疗法的临床治疗益处已在许多临床场景中得到充分证实。然而,我们远未完全理解光子与生物组织相互作用的潜在机制。在进行PBM研究的同时,还有几个平行领域,如进化生物学、光生物学和微生物学等,它们从细胞和组织生理学方面提供了证据。本综述重点在于从更广泛的研究中推断证据,这些研究可能有助于更好地理解PBM机制,尤其关注镇痛作用。此外,还讨论了PBM设备源的选择以及与特定机制相关的剂量学,以促进PBM疗法在更广泛临床中的应用。这篇讨论文章参考了大量同行评审出版物,包括与进化生物学、微生物学、肿瘤学和光光学成像技术等相关的文献。描述了来自许多不同学科的材料。根据当前的证据基础进行推断,提出了一种新理论来部分解释PBM诱导镇痛的细胞基础。有人提出,这可能涉及一类称为解偶联蛋白的跨膜蛋白的活性。此外,有人提出这可能激活热应激蛋白反应,并且细胞内微热梯度可能在PBM镇痛中具有重要意义。有人认为,以阿恩特 - 舒尔茨定律表示的PBM剂量反应作为PBM效应的简单二元模型,在临床上不如多相生物学反应有用。最后,对光子与组织相互作用的性质进行了评论,这对于有效选择和向临床靶点递送剂量可能具有重要意义。有人认为,重新评估光转导途径可能会改善光疗效果。对安全参数的深入了解以及对靶点水平作用机制的更好认识将使临床获益更可靠、可预测,并有助于PBM疗法在更广泛的医学界被接受。