Assistance Publique Hôpitaux de Paris, Centre d'Investigations Cliniques CIC1418, Hôpital Européen Georges Pompidou, Paris, France.
Paris Cardiovascular Research Center PARCC, Inserm UMR970, Paris, France.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2020 Jan;25(1):e12682. doi: 10.1111/anec.12682. Epub 2019 Jul 24.
Ambulatory ECG monitoring is typically achieved using portable devices with limited number of surface leads, autonomy, and length of recording. Smart garments with multiple conductive textile electrodes provide great promise to perform continuous and comfortable ECG monitoring.
We evaluated the ECG signal quality measured on healthy subjects with a smart 12-lead ECG acquisition T-shirt or a 12-lead Holter recording. ECG signals were recorded during 3 min with both techniques in three resting positions (supine, seated, standing) and while walking. Three readers independently assessed ECG patterns and evaluated the denoising of the isoelectric line, the distinction of p waves, R peaks and RR intervals, and the possible appreciation of cardiac rhythm in at least 3 leads.
Thirty healthy subjects (70% males, 29.5 ± 7.8 years) were enrolled in the study. For all three resting conditions, cardiac rhythm was appreciated in 100% of recordings with distinction of p waves, R peaks, and isoelectric line in >97% of recordings. Appreciation of cardiac rhythm was lower in the walking conditions with both techniques (53.3% vs. 46.7%, Holter vs. smart T-shirt, p = .60) mainly due to difficulties to distinguish p waves. These results were consistent across both genders. All ECG parameters (heart rate, PR, QRS and QTC intervals) were comparable between both techniques. No skin irritation was seen with the textile electrodes.
A smart T-shirt with 13 textiles electrodes allows short-duration 12-lead ECG acquisition with quality levels comparable to Holter recordings. The novel device should now be evaluated for long-term non-invasive ECG monitoring.
动态心电图监测通常使用具有有限数量表面导联、自主性和记录长度的便携式设备来实现。具有多个导电纺织电极的智能服装在进行连续和舒适的心电图监测方面具有很大的潜力。
我们评估了健康受试者使用智能 12 导联 ECG 采集 T 恤或 12 导联动态心电图记录仪测量的 ECG 信号质量。两种技术均在三种休息姿势(仰卧、坐姿、站立)和行走时记录 3 分钟的 ECG 信号。三名读者独立评估了 ECG 模式,并评估了等电线路的去噪、p 波、R 波和 RR 间期的区分,以及在至少 3 个导联中可能对心律的评估。
30 名健康受试者(70%为男性,29.5±7.8 岁)纳入本研究。在所有三种休息状态下,两种技术均能在 100%的记录中评估出心律,并能在 >97%的记录中区分出 p 波、R 波和等电线路。在两种技术的行走状态下,对心律的评估均较低(53.3%对 46.7%,动态心电图对智能 T 恤,p=0.60),主要是由于难以区分 p 波。这些结果在两性中均一致。两种技术的所有 ECG 参数(心率、PR、QRS 和 QTC 间期)均相当。纺织电极无皮肤刺激。
带有 13 个纺织电极的智能 T 恤可进行高质量的 12 导联 ECG 短时间采集,与动态心电图记录仪相当。该新型设备现在应评估用于长期非侵入性心电图监测。