School of Communication Science and Disorders, Florida State University, Tallahassee.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2019 Oct 10;50(4):703-709. doi: 10.1044/2019_LSHSS-18-0144. Epub 2019 Jul 24.
Purpose This research note presents a secondary data analysis of language impairment (LI) prevalence rates of children in public schools before and after a statewide mandate for response-to-intervention (RTI) implementation. Method Statewide and district-level LI prevalence rates were compared across 10 school years. Prevalence data from 67 school districts located in 1 state in the United States are reported as the proportion of the general student population (students ages 3-21 years) who were identified with a primary disability of LI. Results The mandated implementation of RTI within special education prereferral, evaluation, and eligibility processes coincided with significant changes in LI prevalence as a primary disability for most of the school districts. The majority of school districts experienced an increase in LI prevalence within 1 school year following RTI implementation. However, the degree and direction of change in prevalence rates varied across some of the school districts. Similar degrees of change were not evident across the other years of prevalence data review, suggesting the systemic change that occurred via RTI requirements coincided with fluctuations in the LI prevalence rates for the majority of school districts in the state. Conclusion A causal relation between RTI and LI prevalence cannot be established with the current data; however, this study establishes a temporal connection between the timing of RTI implementation and changes in LI prevalence in public schools of 1 very large state. Implications are presented for further research investigating the potential impact of systemic mandates on the identification of school-age children with LI. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.8968676.
目的 本研究报告介绍了一项针对全州实施反应干预(RTI)要求前后公立学校儿童语言障碍(LI)患病率的二次数据分析。
方法 比较了 10 个学年全州和地区层面的 LI 患病率。报告了来自美国 1 个州的 67 个学区的数据,这些数据显示了被确定为主要残疾为 LI 的普通学生人群(年龄在 3-21 岁之间的学生)的比例。
结果 在特殊教育预筛选、评估和资格认定过程中强制实施 RTI,与大多数学区作为主要残疾的 LI 患病率发生显著变化同时发生。在实施 RTI 后的 1 个学年内,大多数学区的 LI 患病率都有所增加。然而,在一些学区中,患病率变化的程度和方向有所不同。在其他年份的患病率数据审查中,没有明显的类似变化程度,这表明通过 RTI 要求发生的系统性变化与该州大多数学区的 LI 患病率波动相吻合。
结论 当前数据无法确定 RTI 和 LI 患病率之间存在因果关系;但是,本研究在 RTI 实施时间和公立学校 LI 患病率变化之间建立了时间联系。为进一步研究系统要求对识别学龄儿童 LI 的潜在影响提供了启示。