Colditz G A, Halvorsen K T, Goldhaber S Z
Channing Laboratory, Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115.
Am Heart J. 1988 Jul;116(1 Pt 1):174-80. doi: 10.1016/0002-8703(88)90263-3.
The efficacy of transdermal nitrate patches at 24 hours after application remains controversial. Definitive evaluation has been limited because most randomized trials have had relatively small sample sizes. Therefore, we performed a meta-analysis and combined the results of 17 trials. We assessed exercise test duration as the primary end point. At 3 to 4 hours after patch application, there was a 77-second increase in exercise duration (p = 0.02) for a 5 mg/24 hour dose and a 114-second increase in exercise duration (p = 0.001) for a 10 mg/24 hour dose. At 24 hours, however, the 29-second increase in exercise duration for a 10 mg/24 hour dose was not significant (p greater than 0.1), despite persistent decreases in systolic blood pressure, an increase in heart rate, and a "therapeutic" plasma nitroglycerin concentration. The findings indicate that the 10 mg/24 hour dose is not efficacious at 24 hours after application and support the hypothesis that nitroglycerin's effect on exercise performance is attenuated by nitrate tolerance even though hemodynamic effects and adequate blood levels persist.
应用透皮硝酸酯贴片24小时后的疗效仍存在争议。由于大多数随机试验的样本量相对较小,因此确切的评估受到了限制。因此,我们进行了一项荟萃分析,并汇总了17项试验的结果。我们将运动试验持续时间作为主要终点进行评估。在贴片应用后3至4小时,5mg/24小时剂量组的运动持续时间增加了77秒(p = 0.02),10mg/24小时剂量组的运动持续时间增加了114秒(p = 0.001)。然而,在24小时时,尽管收缩压持续下降、心率增加且血浆硝酸甘油浓度达到“治疗”水平,但10mg/24小时剂量组运动持续时间增加29秒并不显著(p大于0.1)。这些发现表明,10mg/24小时剂量在应用后24小时无效,并支持以下假设:即使血流动力学效应和足够的血药浓度持续存在,但硝酸甘油对运动表现的影响会因硝酸酯耐受性而减弱。