School of Applied and Interdisciplinary Sciences , Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science , 2A and 2B Raja S. C. Mullick Road , Kolkata 700032 , India.
J Phys Chem B. 2019 Aug 22;123(33):7169-7177. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpcb.9b05193. Epub 2019 Aug 8.
This article elucidates H-bonding-regulated directional supramolecular assembly of naphthalene diimide (NDI)-derived unsymmetric cationic bola-shaped π-amphiphiles and systematic investigations on the thermodynamics of their interaction with bacteria mimic lipid vesicles and antimicrobial activity with mechanistic insights. Four NDI-amphiphiles (NDI-1, NDI-2, NDI-3, and NDI-2a) have been studied, all of which contain a central NDI chromophore, a nonionic wedge, an amine containing a head group, and a hydrazide group. In NDI-2 and NDI-2a, the hydrophilic wedge and the head group (pyridine) are the same but the location of the hydrazide group is different. On the basis of this difference, the pyridyl groups are displayed at the outer and inner walls of the vesicle, respectively. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) studies revealed the spontaneous interaction of NDI-2 assembly with bacteria membrane mimic DPPE liposome (Δ = -6.35 kcal/mol), whereas the NDI-2a assembly did not interact at all, confirming a strong influence of the H-bonding-regulated functional group display. On the other hand, the location of the hydrazide group remains the same in NDI-1, NDI-2, and NDI-3, but they differ in the head group structure. ITC binding studies confirmed spontaneous interaction of all three assemblies with DPPE liposome with negative Δ values following the order NDI-1 > NDI-2 > NDI-3, indicating significant influence of the structure of the head group on the interaction with the model membrane. In fact, in all cases, the interaction was favorable both by enthalpy and entropy contribution, indicating dual involvement of the electrostatic interaction and hydrophobic effect. Notably, Δ value for NDI-1 containing a tertiary amine head group was found to be significantly higher than that for NDI-3 containing a primary amine, which is attributed to the enhanced hydrophobic effect in the former case. Furthermore, ITC experiments revealed no interaction by any of these assemblies with the mammalian cell membrane mimic liposome, indicating their high selectivity toward bacterial membranes. Antimicrobial activity studies showed NDI-2 to be lethal selectively against Gram-positive bacteria, whereas NDI-2a did not show any activity. NDI-3 with a primary amine showed moderate activity but no selectivity over the erythrocytes. NDI-1 with the tertiary amine group was found to be the most outstanding candidate, exhibiting broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity with very low minimum inhibitory concentration values of 15.8 and 62 μg/mL for and , respectively, and high selectivity over erythrocytes. These results fully corroborate with the physical insights obtained from the ITC studies on their interaction with the model liposome. Control molecules, lacking either the NDI chromophore or the hydrazide nonionic containing wedge, did not exhibit any notable antibacterial activity. Live-dead assay with fluorescence microscopy studies indicated that the antimicrobial activity of NDI-1 operates through the membrane disruption pathway similar to that of the host defense peptides.
本文阐明了氢键调控的萘二酰亚胺(NDI)衍生的不对称阳离子棒状π-两亲物的指向超分子组装,并系统研究了它们与细菌模拟脂质体的相互作用热力学和抗菌活性及其机制。研究了四种 NDI-两亲物(NDI-1、NDI-2、NDI-3 和 NDI-2a),它们都含有一个中央 NDI 发色团、一个非离子楔形物、一个含有头基的胺和一个酰肼基团。在 NDI-2 和 NDI-2a 中,亲水头基和楔形物(吡啶)相同,但酰肼基团的位置不同。基于这种差异,吡啶基分别显示在囊泡的外壁和内壁上。等温滴定量热法(ITC)研究表明,NDI-2 组装与细菌膜模拟 DPPE 脂质体的自发相互作用(Δ=-6.35 kcal/mol),而 NDI-2a 组装则根本不相互作用,证实了氢键调控的功能基团显示对其具有强烈影响。另一方面,在 NDI-1、NDI-2 和 NDI-3 中,酰肼基团的位置相同,但头基结构不同。ITC 结合研究证实,所有三种组装物都与 DPPE 脂质体自发相互作用,Δ值为负值,遵循 NDI-1>NDI-2>NDI-3 的顺序,表明头基结构对与模型膜的相互作用有显著影响。事实上,在所有情况下,相互作用都是由焓和熵贡献有利的,表明静电相互作用和疏水效应的双重参与。值得注意的是,含有叔胺头基的 NDI-1 的Δ值明显高于含有伯胺的 NDI-3,这归因于前者的疏水效应增强。此外,ITC 实验表明,这些组装物都没有与哺乳动物细胞膜模拟脂质体相互作用,表明它们对细菌膜具有高选择性。抗菌活性研究表明,NDI-2 对革兰氏阳性菌具有选择性致死作用,而 NDI-2a 则没有任何活性。含有伯胺的 NDI-3 表现出中等活性,但对红细胞没有选择性。含有叔胺基的 NDI-1 被发现是最杰出的候选者,对革兰氏阳性菌和革兰氏阴性菌表现出广谱抗菌活性,最低抑菌浓度值分别为 15.8 和 62 μg/mL,对红细胞具有高选择性。这些结果与 ITC 研究中获得的物理见解完全一致,这些见解涉及它们与模型脂质体的相互作用。缺乏 NDI 发色团或酰肼非离子楔形物的对照分子没有表现出任何显著的抗菌活性。荧光显微镜研究的死活测定表明,NDI-1 的抗菌活性通过与宿主防御肽相似的膜破坏途径发挥作用。