Gottlieb Aaron, Sugie Naomi F
University of Illinois at Chicago,
University of California, Irvine,
Justice Q. 2019;36(3):503-531. doi: 10.1080/07418825.2018.1445275. Epub 2018 Apr 11.
A wealth of scholarship generally finds that marriage protects against crime, but there is less consistent evidence for cohabitation. In this article, we contribute to scholarship on marriage and put forward new evidence about cohabitation by examining marital and cohabiting partnerships as transitions with distinct stages of entry, stability, and dissolution. We use within-person change models with contemporary data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 to analyze these stages for the full sample and separately for men and women. The findings show differential protective associations of marriage and cohabitation depending on the stage of the partnership. Both recently formed cohabiting partnerships and stable cohabiting partnerships are associated with reductions in the level of offending, although to a lesser degree than marital relationships. Cohabiting partnerships that are stable, in that they have lasted at least a year, are associated with larger decreases in offending, particularly among women.
大量学术研究普遍发现婚姻能预防犯罪,但关于同居关系的证据则不太一致。在本文中,我们通过将婚姻和同居伴侣关系视为具有不同进入、稳定和解体阶段的转变过程,为婚姻研究做出贡献,并提出关于同居关系的新证据。我们使用来自1997年全国青年纵向调查的当代数据,通过个体内部变化模型对全样本以及分别对男性和女性分析这些阶段。研究结果表明,婚姻和同居关系的保护作用因伴侣关系所处阶段而异。新形成的同居伴侣关系和稳定的同居伴侣关系都与犯罪水平的降低有关,尽管程度低于婚姻关系。持续至少一年的稳定同居伴侣关系与犯罪率的更大幅度下降有关,尤其是在女性中。