Department of Physiotherapy, Faculty of Health Sciences, OsloMet - Oslo Metropolitan University, Oslo, Norway.
Faculty of Community and Health Sciences, University of Western Cape, Cape Town, South Africa.
BMC Med Educ. 2019 Jul 31;19(1):291. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1728-2.
The purpose of the study was to describe the design, implementation and evaluation of a flipped classroom teaching approach in physiotherapy education. The flipped classroom is a blended learning approach in which students receive digital lectures as homework, while active learning activities are used in the classroom. Flipped classroom teaching enables a learning environment that aims to develop higher-order cognitive skills.
The study design was a historically controlled, prospective, cohort study. An eight week theoretical course on musculoskeletal disorders was redesigned, moving from a conventional approach to a flipped classroom model. Pre-class learning material consisted of about 12 h of video lectures and other digital learning resources that were split up over the duration of the course. In-class activities consisted of seven full-day seminars where students worked in groups in order to solve problem-based assignments. The assignments were designed to reflect authentic clinical problems and required critical thinking and reasoning. Outcomes were measured with course-grades and compared with historical controls of conventional teaching, using descriptive statistics. Self-perceived learning outcomes and students' experiences were also collected in a survey.
Fifty-one students passed the course exam, two failed and one did not attend (n = 54). The share of students with Excellent, Very good and Good (ABC) performances increased by more than 10% relative to any previous year. In addition, Satisfactory, Sufficient and Failed performances (DEF) decreased by more than 10%. Almost two thirds of the students preferred the flipped classroom approach as compared with conventional teaching. Interaction with peers and educators, and flexibility, were the most positive factors that were reported by students. Long seminars, time-constraints and low motivation with respect to preparation and educators' roles were the most common complaints.
A flipped classroom approach in physiotherapy education resulted in improved student performances in this professional programme, when compared with conventional teaching. Students responded positively to the collaborative learning environment, especially with respect to the associated autonomy and flexibility. There were indicators that all groups did not work optimally and that accountability to other group members did not always ensure pre-classroom preparations.
本研究旨在描述物理治疗教育中翻转课堂教学方法的设计、实施和评估。翻转课堂是一种混合学习方法,学生将数字讲座作为家庭作业,而在课堂上则使用主动学习活动。翻转课堂教学能够营造一种旨在培养高阶认知技能的学习环境。
研究设计为历史性对照、前瞻性队列研究。对肌肉骨骼疾病的 8 周理论课程进行了重新设计,从传统方法转变为翻转课堂模式。课前学习材料包括约 12 小时的视频讲座和其他数字学习资源,这些资源在课程期间进行了分割。课堂活动包括七个全天研讨会,学生分组合作解决基于问题的作业。这些作业旨在反映真实的临床问题,需要批判性思维和推理。使用描述性统计,通过课程成绩进行了结果衡量,并与传统教学的历史对照进行了比较。还通过调查收集了自我感知的学习成果和学生的经验。
51 名学生通过了课程考试,2 名学生不及格,1 名学生未参加(n=54)。与以往任何一年相比,成绩优秀、非常好和良好(ABC)的学生比例增加了 10%以上。此外,令人满意、足够和失败(DEF)的学生比例下降了 10%以上。与传统教学相比,近三分之二的学生更喜欢翻转课堂方法。学生报告的最积极因素是与同伴和教育者的互动以及灵活性。长时间的研讨会、时间限制以及准备和教育者角色方面的低动力是最常见的抱怨。
与传统教学相比,物理治疗教育中的翻转课堂方法使该专业课程的学生表现得到了提高。学生对协作学习环境反应积极,尤其是与相关的自主性和灵活性。有迹象表明,并非所有群体都能发挥最佳作用,而且对其他群体成员的问责制并不总能确保课前准备。