Tanner Carmen, Gangl Katharina, Witt Nicole
Leadership Excellence Institute Zeppelin, Zeppelin University, Friedrichshafen, Germany.
Department of Banking and Finance, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Front Psychol. 2019 Jul 16;10:1667. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01667. eCollection 2019.
Misconduct in organizations (such as fraud, stealing, deception, and harming others) is not only a matter of some "bad apples" but also related to the organizational context ("bad barrels"), which can facilitate either ethical or unethical behaviors. Given the financial crisis and recurring corporate ethics scandals, policymakers, regulators and organizations are interested in how to change their organizational cultures to enhance ethical behavior and to prevent further disasters. For this purpose, organizations need to better understand what strategies and factors of the organizational environment can affect (un)ethical behavior. However, to assess the corporate ethical culture, solid measures are required. Since there is an urgent need to have a German measure to promote research in German-speaking countries, this research developed and tested the German Ethical Culture Scale (GECS). Drawing on a prominent approach that has received much attention from scholars and practitioners alike, the GECS attempts to integrate the notion of compliance- and integrity-based ethics programs (with its focus on how to steer organizations) with the notion of ethical culture (with its focus on what factors inhibit or foster ethical behavior). Three studies with heterogeneous samples of German and Swiss employees and managers were conducted to develop, test and validate the multidimensional scale (total > 2000). Overall, the studies provide first evidence of the measure's construct, criteria-related and incremental validity. The paper concludes with a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of the GECS and implications for future research.
组织中的不当行为(如欺诈、偷窃、欺骗和伤害他人)不仅是一些“坏苹果”的问题,还与组织环境(“坏桶”)有关,这可能会助长道德或不道德行为。鉴于金融危机和反复出现的企业道德丑闻,政策制定者、监管机构和组织都对如何改变组织文化以增强道德行为和防止进一步灾难感兴趣。为此,组织需要更好地了解组织环境的哪些策略和因素会影响(不)道德行为。然而,要评估企业道德文化,需要可靠的衡量标准。由于迫切需要一种德语衡量标准来促进德语国家的研究,本研究开发并测试了德语道德文化量表(GECS)。GECS借鉴了一种受到学者和从业者广泛关注的突出方法,试图将基于合规和诚信的道德计划(侧重于如何引导组织)的概念与道德文化(侧重于哪些因素抑制或促进道德行为)的概念结合起来。我们对德国和瑞士的员工及管理人员进行了三项异质样本研究,以开发、测试和验证这个多维量表(总计>2000)。总体而言,这些研究首次提供了该量表在结构效度、标准关联效度和增量效度方面的证据。本文最后讨论了GECS的优缺点以及对未来研究的启示。