Doctor of Public Health Candidate, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health , Boston , MA , USA.
Taro Takemi Research Professor of International Health Policy, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health , Boston , MA , USA.
Health Syst Reform. 2019;5(3):224-235. doi: 10.1080/23288604.2019.1625251. Epub 2019 Aug 7.
Any effort to improve health system performance must address the challenges of policy implementation. This article examines one aspect of implementation-the politics of policy implementation for the health sector, particularly the management of stakeholders in order to help change teams improve the chances of achieving policy objectives. Based on a literature scan of political analyses and descriptions of health policy implementation in low- and middle-income countries, we propose six major categories of stakeholder groups that are likely to influence implementation: interest group politics, bureaucratic politics, budget politics, leadership politics, beneficiary politics, and external actor politics. The categories of stakeholders can be overlapping. We examine the politics of these different stakeholder categories, and then present selected examples of published case studies that show the types of implementation challenges that arise for each category and how implementers can use political strategies to manage specific stakeholder groups and related political processes. Understanding the political dimensions of implementation can help those responsible for implementation drive policy into practice more effectively. Understanding and addressing conflict, resistance and cooperation among stakeholders are key to managing the implementation process. Systematic and continuous political analysis can help decision makers and change teams improve the chances for successful implementation.
任何提高卫生系统绩效的努力都必须应对政策实施的挑战。本文探讨了实施的一个方面——卫生部门政策实施的政治,特别是为帮助变革团队提高实现政策目标的机会而对利益相关者进行的管理。本文基于对中低收入国家卫生政策实施的政治分析和描述的文献扫描,提出了可能影响实施的六个主要利益相关者群体类别:利益集团政治、官僚政治、预算政治、领导政治、受益方政治和外部行为体政治。这些利益相关者群体的类别可能会重叠。我们研究了这些不同利益相关者群体的政治,然后展示了一些已发表的案例研究,这些案例研究说明了每个类别在实施过程中出现的实施挑战类型,以及实施者如何利用政治策略来管理特定的利益相关者群体和相关的政治进程。了解实施的政治层面可以帮助负责实施的人员更有效地将政策付诸实践。理解和解决利益相关者之间的冲突、抵制和合作是管理实施过程的关键。系统和持续的政治分析可以帮助决策者和变革团队提高成功实施的机会。