Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
BMC Med Educ. 2019 Aug 8;19(1):304. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1740-6.
Experiential learning through service provides opportunities to nurture and practice empathy. Of growing concern, studies showed significantly decreased empathy scores as students progress through medical school. Additionally, peer-to-peer learning provides an effective way for students to learn. Constructing Care Collaboration (CCC) is a student initiated, structured-service-learning-program that promotes the development of empathy and peer-to-peer teaching. CCC is conducted in cycles of 6 sessions. This is a mixed methods study that explores the effectiveness of CCC as a service learning platform in developing student participants' empathy, social and cultural competencies, communication skills and peer-to-peer teaching skills, ultimately aiming to promote a culture of serving the underprivileged.
The study comprised of a self-administered quantitative questionnaire and qualitative interviews. Both evaluated if CCC participation developed volunteers' social-awareness, cultural competency, communication, confidence and motivation to teach their peers.
Quantitative data were collated from 38 completed student volunteers' questionnaires. Volunteers generally agreed CCC improved social-awareness and cultural competency. It increased confidence of participants in approaching migrant-workers, communicating with people from different social backgrounds, and promoted a culture of peer-to-peer teaching. Thematic analysis of 17 interviews was conducted. Themes identified include: increased empathy towards migrant-workers, improved communication skills, and identifying benefits and challenges in peer-to-peer teaching.
From the quantitative and qualitative information gathered, CCC has been shown to be effective in nurturing participants' self-reported empathy, cultural competence, communication skills and improved attitude towards peer-to-peer teaching. Given its effectiveness, CCC can be adopted as a model for structured service-learning.
通过服务进行体验式学习为培养和实践同理心提供了机会。越来越令人担忧的是,研究表明,随着学生在医学院的进步,同理心分数显著下降。此外,同伴学习为学生提供了一种有效的学习方式。构建关怀协作(CCC)是一个由学生发起的、结构化的服务学习计划,旨在促进同理心和同伴教学的发展。CCC 以 6 个周期进行。这是一项混合方法研究,旨在探讨 CCC 作为服务学习平台在培养学生参与者同理心、社交和文化能力、沟通技巧和同伴教学技巧方面的有效性,最终旨在促进服务弱势群体的文化。
该研究包括一份自我管理的定量问卷和定性访谈。两者都评估了 CCC 参与是否培养了志愿者的社会意识、文化能力、沟通能力、信心和向同龄人传授知识的积极性。
从 38 名完成的学生志愿者问卷中收集了定量数据。志愿者普遍认为 CCC 提高了社会意识和文化能力。它提高了参与者接近农民工、与来自不同社会背景的人交流以及促进同伴教学文化的信心。对 17 次访谈进行了主题分析。确定的主题包括:对农民工的同理心增强、沟通技巧提高,以及在同伴教学中发现的好处和挑战。
从收集的定量和定性信息来看,CCC 已被证明在培养参与者自我报告的同理心、文化能力、沟通技巧和改善对同伴教学的态度方面是有效的。鉴于其有效性,CCC 可以作为结构化服务学习的模式。