Bufman Hila, Sagi Orli, Shemer Yonat, Horev Amir, Justman Naphtali, Bazarsky Elina, Ben-Shimol Shalom
Pediatric Infectious Disease Unit; Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev; Parasitology Laboratory, Soroka University Medical Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel.
J Vector Borne Dis. 2019 Apr-Jun;56(2):159-165. doi: 10.4103/0972-9062.263723.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES: Clinical diagnosis of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) may bear a high rate of false diagnosis. This study assessed CL-suspected episodes, in an attempt to differentiate confirmed CL and non-CL diagnoses.
In this retrospective, case-control study, medical files of CL-suspected episodes, tested by a biopsy for Leishmania-PCR, from 2013 to 2016, were collected and analysed statistically.
Of 324 suspected CL episodes, 48.8% were PCR-confirmed CL (96.2% Leishmania major) and 51.2% were non-CL (57.1% bacterial infections). Overall, 59.3% episodes were in males. Mean (± SD) duration until diagnosis was 3.7 ± 7.2 months. Lesions (mean 2.9 ± 3.8 per episode) were mostly (60.8%) sampled from September through February. Ulcer, pain, itching, purulent discharge and fever were recorded in 55.2, 47, 42.9, 18.2 and 4.7% of episodes, respectively. Univariate analysis showed that male gender, multiple lesions, ulcer, >1-month duration until diagnosis, and seasonality were associated with CL. Empiric CL treatment was recorded in 63.4 and 16% of CL-confirmed and non-CL episodes, respectively (p <0.001); and was observed to be associated with Jewish ethnicity, seasonality, multiple lesions, ulcer, absence of fever and duration of >1-month until diagnosis. In multivariate analysis, seasonality (odds ratio, OR = 2.144), empiric CL treatment (OR = 5.144) and ulcer (OR = 2.459) were associated with CL. Empiric CL treatment was associated with Jewish ethnicity (OR = 2.446) and duration of >1-month until diagnosis (OR = 3.304).
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSION: CL diagnosis should be laboratory confirmed, as clinical appearance is often misleading. Seasonality, ulcer appearance and gender may aid in correct identification and treatment of CL cases.
皮肤利什曼病(CL)的临床诊断可能存在较高的误诊率。本研究对疑似CL的病例进行评估,以区分确诊的CL和非CL诊断。
在这项回顾性病例对照研究中,收集了2013年至2016年通过活检进行利什曼原虫聚合酶链反应(Leishmania-PCR)检测的疑似CL病例的医疗档案,并进行统计分析。
在324例疑似CL病例中,48.8%经PCR确诊为CL(96.2%为硕大利什曼原虫),51.2%为非CL(57.1%为细菌感染)。总体而言,59.3%的病例为男性。确诊前的平均(±标准差)病程为3.7±7.2个月。病变(平均每次发作2.9±3.8个)大多(60.8%)在9月至次年2月取样。分别有55.2%、47%、42.9%、18.2%和4.7%的病例记录有溃疡、疼痛、瘙痒、脓性分泌物和发热。单因素分析显示,男性、多发病变、溃疡、确诊前病程>1个月以及季节性与CL相关。在确诊为CL和非CL的病例中,分别有63.4%和16%的病例接受了经验性CL治疗(p<0.001);且观察到经验性CL治疗与犹太种族、季节性、多发病变、溃疡、无发热以及确诊前病程>1个月有关。多因素分析显示,季节性(比值比,OR=2.144)、经验性CL治疗(OR=5.144)和溃疡(OR=2.459)与CL相关。经验性CL治疗与犹太种族(OR=2.446)和确诊前病程>1个月(OR=3.304)有关。
由于临床表现常常具有误导性,CL的诊断应通过实验室确诊。季节性、溃疡表现和性别可能有助于正确识别和治疗CL病例。