Staples Eric, Sangster-Gormley Esther
Independent Nursing Practice Consultant, Ancaster, ON, Canada.
Faculty of Human and Social Development, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC, Canada.
Int J Nurs Sci. 2018 Apr 3;5(2):115-120. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnss.2018.03.005. eCollection 2018 Apr 10.
Clinical experience is an essential component of nurse practitioner (NP) education that relies heavily on preceptors. Recruitment and retention of preceptors is challenging due to many variables that can affect NP education and practice. We surveyed Canadian NP programs to understand their preceptorship structures, how they support preceptorship, and to identify gaps and challenges to recruitment and retention of preceptors.
An 18-item survey, developed by the NP Education Interest Group, was distributed to 24 universities across 10 Canadian provinces. Construct validity and reliability was assessed by experienced NPs and NP faculty. Data were analyzed using relative frequency statistics and thematic analysis. Participants consisted of administrative staff and/or faculty designated as responsible for recruitment and retention of NP preceptors.
Seventeen returned surveys were analyzed and demonstrated more similarities than differences across Canada's NP programs, particularly related to barriers affecting recruitment and retention of preceptors. The findings identified NP programs have too many students for the number of available clinical sites/preceptors, resulting in overutilization, burnout, or refusal to take students. Competition with other health disciplines for clinical placements was identified as a challenge to placements. Respondents commented they lack time to recruit, provide follow-up, offer support, or seek preceptors' feedback due to competing work demands. They identified the need for standardized funding for preceptor remuneration and recognition across the country.
The findings suggest the need for exploring a wider intraprofessional collaboration among graduate NP programs/faculty, clinical placement sites, and NPs to facilitate the recruitment and retention of preceptors.
临床经验是执业护士(NP)教育的重要组成部分,严重依赖带教老师。由于许多可能影响NP教育和实践的变量,带教老师的招募和留用具有挑战性。我们对加拿大的NP项目进行了调查,以了解其带教结构、如何支持带教工作,并确定带教老师招募和留用方面的差距与挑战。
由NP教育兴趣小组制定的一份包含18个条目的调查问卷,被分发给加拿大10个省的24所大学。经验丰富的NP和NP教员对结构效度和信度进行了评估。使用相对频率统计和主题分析对数据进行了分析。参与者包括被指定负责NP带教老师招募和留用的行政人员和/或教员。
对17份回复的调查问卷进行了分析,结果表明加拿大的NP项目之间的相似之处多于差异,特别是在影响带教老师招募和留用的障碍方面。研究结果表明,NP项目的学生数量相对于可用临床实习点/带教老师的数量过多,导致过度使用、倦怠或拒绝接收学生。与其他健康学科竞争临床实习点被确定为实习安排的一个挑战。受访者表示,由于工作需求相互冲突,他们缺乏时间进行招募、跟进、提供支持或寻求带教老师的反馈。他们指出需要在全国范围内为带教老师的薪酬和认可提供标准化资金。
研究结果表明,需要在研究生NP项目/教员、临床实习点和NP之间探索更广泛的专业内合作,以促进带教老师的招募和留用。