Liver Center, Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA,
Department of Medicine and Gastroenterology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, Elmhurst Hospital Center, Elmhurst, Illinois, USA.
Dig Dis. 2020;38(1):46-52. doi: 10.1159/000501821. Epub 2019 Aug 16.
Chronic hepatitis C (CHC) viral infection has a major impact on our health care system. The emergence of direct-acting antiviral agents (DAA) has made treatment simple (oral), efficacious, and safe. However, treatment is expensive and access is variable. Despite great treatment outcomes, only a minority of patients with CHC receive antiviral therapy. This study identifies the barriers to treatment in CHC infection.
Study recruited all hepatitis C antibody-positive patients between 2012 and 2016 from a large academic teaching hospital in New York City. Demographic information, clinical data, and insurance information were reviewed. Statistical analysis performed with OR and p < 0.05 reported.
A total of 1,548 patients with hepatitis C antibody-positive titer were included in the initial analysis. One thousand and twenty-four patients were forwarded to the final analysis after exclusion of 524 patients (for distant resolved hepatitis C viral [HCV] infection [n = 42], patients cured with interferon-based regimens [n = 94], patients with comorbid conditions [n = 176], and patients with an incomplete medical chart [n = 212]). In the intention to treat cohort of 1,024 patients, 204 patients achieved a sustained virological response after receiving DAAs (n = 204/1,024 - 20%). The majority of patients had not received DAAs (n = 816/1,024 patients - 80%). Multiple factors resulted in hepatitis C viral infection (HCV) patients not receiving DAAs including the following primary factors: (a) lost to follow-up clinic visits and poor adherence to clinic appointments (n = 548 [67%]; p value <0.0001), (b) active substance abuse (alcoholism and IV drug abuse; n = 165 [20%]; p value 0.22), (c) patients with significant psychiatric illness (n = 103 [12.7%]; p value 0.015), and subgroup analysis revealed that 188 (188/1,024 - 12%) patients had human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) and HCV coinfection. Majority of HCV/HIV coinfected patients had not received DAAs (n = 176 [97%]; p value <0.0001, OR 4.46). The etiology of nontreatment in coinfected HIV/HCV patients was 73.3% poor adherence, 11.5% active substance abuse including alcohol and IV drug use, and 9% significant psychiatric illness and 6.2% multiple reasons for not receiving HCV treatment.
Multifactorial barriers are preventing hepatitis C patients from receiving effective DAA therapy. Primary factors include poor compliance, substance abuse, and significant psychiatric illness, with significant overlap between these groups. Subgroup analysis showed a substantial number of high-risk patients with HIV/HCV coinfection did not receive DAA therapy. A multidisciplinary clinic approach with a hepatologist, ID physicians, social worker, and behavioral health psychologist and case manager should provide a solution to improve diagnosis and treatment with DAA.
慢性丙型肝炎(CHC)病毒感染对我们的医疗体系有重大影响。直接作用抗病毒药物(DAA)的出现使治疗变得简单(口服)、有效且安全。然而,治疗费用昂贵,且获得途径也各不相同。尽管治疗效果显著,但只有少数 CHC 患者接受了抗病毒治疗。本研究旨在确定 CHC 感染治疗的障碍。
研究于 2012 年至 2016 年期间从纽约市一家大型学术教学医院招募了所有丙型肝炎抗体阳性患者。回顾了人口统计学信息、临床数据和保险信息。采用 OR 进行统计分析,p 值<0.05 有统计学意义。
在最初的分析中,共有 1548 名丙型肝炎抗体阳性患者纳入研究。排除 524 名患者(因既往已治愈 HCV 感染[ n = 42]、因干扰素治疗已治愈[ n = 94]、合并其他疾病[ n = 176]或病历不完整[ n = 212])后,1024 名患者进入最终分析。在 1024 名意向治疗患者中,204 名患者在接受 DAA 治疗后获得持续病毒学应答(n = 204/1024-20%)。大多数患者未接受 DAA 治疗(n = 816/1024 例患者-80%)。导致 HCV 患者未接受 DAA 治疗的多种因素包括以下主要因素:(a)失访和不遵医嘱(n = 548[67%];p 值<0.0001),(b)物质滥用(酒精和静脉药物滥用;n = 165[20%];p 值 0.22),(c)有显著精神疾病(n = 103[12.7%];p 值 0.015)。亚组分析显示,188 名(188/1024-12%)患者 HIV-1 和 HCV 合并感染。大多数合并感染 HIV/HCV 的患者未接受 DAA 治疗(n = 176[97%];p 值<0.0001,OR 4.46)。合并感染 HIV/HCV 的患者未接受治疗的病因分别为:73.3%的患者依从性差、11.5%的患者物质滥用(包括酒精和静脉药物滥用)、9%的患者有显著精神疾病和 6.2%的患者有多种原因未接受 HCV 治疗。
多种因素导致丙型肝炎患者无法接受有效的 DAA 治疗。主要因素包括依从性差、物质滥用和显著精神疾病,这些因素之间存在显著重叠。亚组分析显示,大量合并 HIV/HCV 感染的高危患者未接受 DAA 治疗。由肝病专家、传染病医生、社会工作者、行为健康心理学家和个案经理组成的多学科诊所方法应能提供一个改善 DAA 诊断和治疗的解决方案。