Andersson I, Aspegren K, Janzon L, Landberg T, Lindholm K, Linell F, Ljungberg O, Ranstam J, Sigfússon B
Department of Radiology, Malmö General Hospital, Sweden.
BMJ. 1988 Oct 15;297(6654):943-8. doi: 10.1136/bmj.297.6654.943.
To determine whether mortality from breast cancer could be reduced by repeated mammographic screening.
Birth year cohorts of city population separately randomised into study and control groups.
Screening clinic outside main hospital.
Women aged over 45; 21,088 invited for screening and 21,195 in control group.
Women in the study group were invited to attend for mammographic screening at intervals of 18-24 months. Five rounds of screening were completed. Breast cancer was treated according to stage at diagnosis.
Mortality from breast cancer.
All women were followed up and classed at end point as alive without breast cancer, alive with breast cancer, dead from breast cancer, or dead from other causes. Cause of death was taken from national mortality registry and for patients with breast cancer was validated independently. Mean follow up was 8.8 years. Altogether 588 cases of breast cancer were diagnosed in the study group and 447 in the control group; 99 v 94 women died of all causes and 63 v 66 women died of breast cancer (no significant difference; relative risk 0.96 (95% confidence interval 0.68 to 1.35)). In the study group 29% more women aged less than 55 died of breast cancer (28 v 22; relative risk 1.29 (0.74 to 2.25)). More women in the study group died from breast cancer in the first seven years; after that the trend reversed, especially in women aged greater than or equal to 55 at entry. Overall, women in the study group aged greater than or equal to 55 had a 20% reduction in mortality from breast cancer (35 v 44; relative risk 0.79 (0.51 to 1.24)). OTHER FINDINGS: In the study group 100 (17%) cancers appeared in intervals between screenings and 107 (18%) in non-attenders; 51 of these women died from breast cancer. Cancers classed as stages II-IV comprised 33% (190/579) of cancers in the study group and 52% (231/443) in the control group.
Invitation to mammographic screening may lead to reduced mortality from breast cancer, at least in women aged 55 or over.
确定重复进行乳房X线筛查是否可降低乳腺癌死亡率。
将城市人口按出生年份队列分别随机分为研究组和对照组。
主医院外的筛查诊所。
45岁以上女性;21088名受邀参加筛查,21195名在对照组。
研究组女性受邀每隔18 - 24个月参加一次乳房X线筛查。共完成五轮筛查。乳腺癌根据诊断时的分期进行治疗。
乳腺癌死亡率。
对所有女性进行随访,在终点时分为无乳腺癌存活、患乳腺癌存活、死于乳腺癌或死于其他原因。死亡原因取自国家死亡率登记处,乳腺癌患者的死亡原因经独立验证。平均随访8.8年。研究组共诊断出588例乳腺癌,对照组为447例;99名对94名女性死于各种原因,63名对66名女性死于乳腺癌(无显著差异;相对风险0.96(95%置信区间0.68至1.35))。研究组中年龄小于55岁的女性死于乳腺癌的人数多29%(28例对22例;相对风险1.29(0.74至2.25))。研究组中更多女性在头七年死于乳腺癌;此后趋势逆转,尤其是入组时年龄大于或等于55岁的女性。总体而言,研究组中年龄大于或等于55岁的女性乳腺癌死亡率降低了20%(35例对44例;相对风险0.79(0.51至1.24))。
研究组中有100例(17%)癌症出现在筛查间隔期,107例(18%)出现在未参加筛查者中;其中51名女性死于乳腺癌。研究组中II - IV期癌症占癌症总数的33%(190/579),对照组为52%(231/443)。
邀请进行乳房X线筛查可能会降低乳腺癌死亡率,至少在55岁及以上女性中如此。